Would you play Dalvin Pre-season game #1?
No way. Not even if the whole offensive line was intact. I expect it to be a shit show offensively for Minnesota with Remmers, Elflein and Easton out for that game.
Yes I would. Just one series. GIve him a carry and let him get that first hit in and over with.
If he's healed up, then probably. If he doesn't, then the coaches most likely don't feel he's ready. I won't be surprised to see him on a few plays.
if we are going to trust our 84 million dollar QB to that line, then give him every weapon he has at his disposal. if DC is able to be a full go in practice, this is the next logical step and if he is going to suffer a set back it could just as well happen this week than waiting until week 3 of the preseason. he runs with the 1s so get him out there, of course I would want to see Murray getting some reps with the 1s as well.
No. I'd let him play a couple series in that 3rd game, but that's it.
Last season was easily our best in many years. But in the preseason they looked awful. Just terrible. They clearly didn't show any of the key formations, plays, blitzes that were so successful in week one against the Saints. And I'm good with that. Let other teams win the preseason. Use the preseason to work on fundamentals, but don't let anyone see what's in store when it counts.
@"MaroonBells" said: No. I'd let him play a couple series in that 3rd game, but that's it.Last season was easily our best in many years. But in the preseason they looked awful. Just terrible. They clearly didn't show any of the key formations, plays, blitzes that were so successful in week one against the Saints. And I'm good with that. Let other teams win the preseason. Use the preseason to work on fundamentals, but don't let anyone see what's in store when it counts.
he hasnt taken a football hit in nearly a year, I understand wanting to keep it vanilla and protect him, but he is a football player and needs to take some football hits. even if he is only in for half a series IMO he needs to get his body ready to play the game again. practice is good, but its still not football.
@"JimmyinSD" said:@"MaroonBells" said: No. I'd let him play a couple series in that 3rd game, but that's it.Last season was easily our best in many years. But in the preseason they looked awful. Just terrible. They clearly didn't show any of the key formations, plays, blitzes that were so successful in week one against the Saints. And I'm good with that. Let other teams win the preseason. Use the preseason to work on fundamentals, but don't let anyone see what's in store when it counts.
he hasnt taken a football hit in nearly a year, I understand wanting to keep it vanilla and protect him, but he is a football player and needs to take some football hits. even if he is only in for half a series IMO he needs to get his body ready to play the game again. practice is good, but its still not football.
I don't know that it's that important. He's likely been knocking heads since puberty. It's not like he doesn't know what that's about. I'd put him in that 3rd game dress rehearsal but wouldn't expose him to a dozen defenders trying to make a football team. We don't have to agree. PF just asked what I would do and that's what I would do.
Chad Greenway was on with PA yesterday. Said that it was very important for him to get into that first preseason game after his knee injury. Said you need to get that first hit by an opponent done right away.
I agree with jimmyinsd, get DC a few carries this week, then rest him.
I'd give him a series...maybe two...but I'd seriously limit the way we used him...
He got dinged in every single FSU game he ever played in but always returned the same game. He's tough. And he needs to trust that knee, which was the only part he never hurt as a Nole.
Get him some reps. Especially with the backup Guards. He needs to get a feel for how they block during live fire in case they are pressed into service during the season, which virtually every team can count on now a days.
Hell to the yeah. Only one or two series. He needs to get the first hit and shake it off. It's also important to help get rid of the rust.
@"Hidalgo" said: 3 plays, 3 touchdowns, 153 yardsThat was almost Moss' line vs the Cowboys on Thanksgiving...
@"BarrNone55" said:I was there. One of 4 games I got to that year. Would love to see DC echo Randy's on the field legacy@"Hidalgo" said: 3 plays, 3 touchdowns, 153 yards That was almost Moss' line vs the Cowboys on Thanksgiving...
@"BarrNone55" said:Thats funny, I thought the same damn thing when I read that lol!@"Hidalgo" said: 3 plays, 3 touchdowns, 153 yards That was almost Moss' line vs the Cowboys on Thanksgiving...
Hell yes I would. It pissed me off when Prima Dona Peterson would not play in pre-season, and then was not ready for Game 1. It took him too long to get in stride when he did that, and that was when he was still in his prime. Get him in some dings. Not a lot to abuse him...just enough to get him used to serious physical combat again.
I would not play Cousins/Cook/Theilan/Diggs one play in preseason game 1.
Edit Post (mod action — author will see a notice)
Warn Poster
Suspend User (3 days)
The user will be suspended for 3 days and will receive an email with the reason and information about how to appeal.