It feels like a Kwesi thing to do, taking another teams highly
rated castoff and hoping for that player to blossom and be a cheap but
productive player. Is this his contract
#’s for the trading team? 2023: $940k (if they paid his training camp roster
bonus or $3.7M if we do) 2024: $5.3M
I just struggle with the same challenges everyone above
listed out. If he showed any real
promise of not being a bust, I think they’d keep him and let his value build. But it really comes down to whether you think
Hall can develop more over 4 years than Lance can over 2. I guess there’s another option which would be
to roll with Cousins, Hall, and Lance, and then if Cousins goes down with a big
injury hit the FA market for a vet QB or tank for better draft picks.
Quote: @StickyBun said:
@ Chuckf said:
@ StickyBun said:
It's official. What a colossally bad trade up they made for Trey Lance. Horrible. Purdy seems to have saved them, but let's not count those chickens yet.
Yeah you can. The kid played at a high level consistently for 3 years in the Big 12. Will he be a Tom Brady? Who knows but he is worlds above Lance or Darnold at this time. He is a LOT more athletic than you think, he ran the RPO at ISU at times and was extremely good running the football.
I don't trust anyone after only 1 year. And neither should you.
![[Image: wpid-20150507__150507_MattKalil_vikings_skybox.jpg]](https://www.twincities.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/wpid-20150507__150507_MattKalil_vikings_skybox.jpg)
Big difference Sticky, while I agree with you one year does not a career make, BUT, Purdy LOVES the game, Matt Kalil didn't. Purdy beat Oregon in a New Years day bowl at IOWA STATE!! He played Clemson to a 20-13 loss at IOWA STATE. Extremely high football I.Q. and character guy.
So if Shanahan’s offense is so QB friendly, how come they all keep getting hurt?
Quote: @Chuckf said:
@ StickyBun said:
@ Chuckf said:
@ StickyBun said:
It's official. What a colossally bad trade up they made for Trey Lance. Horrible. Purdy seems to have saved them, but let's not count those chickens yet.
Yeah you can. The kid played at a high level consistently for 3 years in the Big 12. Will he be a Tom Brady? Who knows but he is worlds above Lance or Darnold at this time. He is a LOT more athletic than you think, he ran the RPO at ISU at times and was extremely good running the football.
I don't trust anyone after only 1 year. And neither should you.
Big difference Sticky, while I agree with you one year does not a career make, BUT, Purdy LOVES the game, Matt Kalil didn't. Purdy beat Oregon in a New Years day bowl at IOWA STATE!! He played Clemson to a 20-13 loss at IOWA STATE. Extremely high football I.Q. and character guy.
I'm rooting for a guy like Purdy, from what I've read a great kid. And he for sure had a nice career in college, no doubt about it. But Year 2 for a QB is always much tougher, just ask Mac Jones.
@ StickyBun said: Quote:
@ Chuckf said:
@ StickyBun said:
@ Chuckf said:
@ StickyBun said:
It's official. What a colossally bad trade up they made for Trey Lance. Horrible. Purdy seems to have saved them, but let's not count those chickens yet.
Yeah you can. The kid played at a high level consistently for 3 years in the Big 12. Will he be a Tom Brady? Who knows but he is worlds above Lance or Darnold at this time. He is a LOT more athletic than you think, he ran the RPO at ISU at times and was extremely good running the football.
I don't trust anyone after only 1 year. And neither should you.
Big difference Sticky, while I agree with you one year does not a career make, BUT, Purdy LOVES the game, Matt Kalil didn't. Purdy beat Oregon in a New Years day bowl at IOWA STATE!! He played Clemson to a 20-13 loss at IOWA STATE. Extremely high football I.Q. and character guy.
I'm rooting for a guy like Purdy, from what I've read a great kid. And he for sure had a nice career in college, no doubt about it. But Year 2 for a QB is always much tougher, just ask Mac Jones.
I like Purdy and I like what the 49ers are doing, but mostly
I think they’ve had enough success and am hoping that they’re on the outside
looking in for a while.
Quote: @medaille said:
@StickyBun said:
@ Chuckf said:
@ StickyBun said:
@ Chuckf said:
@ StickyBun said:
It's official. What a colossally bad trade up they made for Trey Lance. Horrible. Purdy seems to have saved them, but let's not count those chickens yet.
Yeah you can. The kid played at a high level consistently for 3 years in the Big 12. Will he be a Tom Brady? Who knows but he is worlds above Lance or Darnold at this time. He is a LOT more athletic than you think, he ran the RPO at ISU at times and was extremely good running the football.
I don't trust anyone after only 1 year. And neither should you.
Big difference Sticky, while I agree with you one year does not a career make, BUT, Purdy LOVES the game, Matt Kalil didn't. Purdy beat Oregon in a New Years day bowl at IOWA STATE!! He played Clemson to a 20-13 loss at IOWA STATE. Extremely high football I.Q. and character guy.
I'm rooting for a guy like Purdy, from what I've read a great kid. And he for sure had a nice career in college, no doubt about it. But Year 2 for a QB is always much tougher, just ask Mac Jones.
I like Purdy and I like what the 49ers are doing, but mostly
I think they’ve had enough success and am hoping that they’re on the outside
looking in for a while.
That would be nice. But if Purdy can repeat what he did last year, and I'm not yet convinced of that, the 49ers have to be a big favorite in the NFC along with the Eagles.
Quote: @MaroonBells said:
@ medaille said:
@ StickyBun said:
@ Chuckf said:
@ StickyBun said:
@ Chuckf said:
@ StickyBun said:
It's official. What a colossally bad trade up they made for Trey Lance. Horrible. Purdy seems to have saved them, but let's not count those chickens yet.
Yeah you can. The kid played at a high level consistently for 3 years in the Big 12. Will he be a Tom Brady? Who knows but he is worlds above Lance or Darnold at this time. He is a LOT more athletic than you think, he ran the RPO at ISU at times and was extremely good running the football.
I don't trust anyone after only 1 year. And neither should you.
Big difference Sticky, while I agree with you one year does not a career make, BUT, Purdy LOVES the game, Matt Kalil didn't. Purdy beat Oregon in a New Years day bowl at IOWA STATE!! He played Clemson to a 20-13 loss at IOWA STATE. Extremely high football I.Q. and character guy.
I'm rooting for a guy like Purdy, from what I've read a great kid. And he for sure had a nice career in college, no doubt about it. But Year 2 for a QB is always much tougher, just ask Mac Jones.
I like Purdy and I like what the 49ers are doing, but mostly
I think they’ve had enough success and am hoping that they’re on the outside
looking in for a while.
That would be nice. But if Purdy can repeat what he did last year, and I'm not yet convinced of that, the 49ers have to be a big favorite in the NFC along with the Eagles.
aside from the injury bug, the only thing likely holding them back would be QB play.
Quote: @JimmyinSD said:
@ MaroonBells said:
@ medaille said:
@ StickyBun said:
@ Chuckf said:
@ StickyBun said:
@ Chuckf said:
@ StickyBun said:
It's official. What a colossally bad trade up they made for Trey Lance. Horrible. Purdy seems to have saved them, but let's not count those chickens yet.
Yeah you can. The kid played at a high level consistently for 3 years in the Big 12. Will he be a Tom Brady? Who knows but he is worlds above Lance or Darnold at this time. He is a LOT more athletic than you think, he ran the RPO at ISU at times and was extremely good running the football.
I don't trust anyone after only 1 year. And neither should you.
Big difference Sticky, while I agree with you one year does not a career make, BUT, Purdy LOVES the game, Matt Kalil didn't. Purdy beat Oregon in a New Years day bowl at IOWA STATE!! He played Clemson to a 20-13 loss at IOWA STATE. Extremely high football I.Q. and character guy.
I'm rooting for a guy like Purdy, from what I've read a great kid. And he for sure had a nice career in college, no doubt about it. But Year 2 for a QB is always much tougher, just ask Mac Jones.
I like Purdy and I like what the 49ers are doing, but mostly
I think they’ve had enough success and am hoping that they’re on the outside
looking in for a while.
That would be nice. But if Purdy can repeat what he did last year, and I'm not yet convinced of that, the 49ers have to be a big favorite in the NFC along with the Eagles.
aside from the injury bug, the only thing likely holding them back would be QB play.
I see Purdy getting hurt or pulled for sucking, and Darnold leading them to a SB ala Dilfer.
Lance to Dallas for a 4th round pick
|
