Forum The Longship Roster Depth

Roster Depth

TY
Tyr
Joined Mar 2014
27 posts
Rep: 17

While the Vikings have a strong roster, they have lost a lot of players this season. They can fill some of that void through the draft and rookie free agents and while they may be trying to stockpile some compensation picks for next year, I have some mild concerns about them being able to fill out the roster with quality & experienced players.

Notable players we have lost:

RG Joe Berger (Retired)
QB Sam Bradford
QB Teddy Bridgewater
CB Tremaine Brock
WR Michael Floyd (not expected to be re-signed)
UT Sharrif Floyd (injuries)
UT Tom Johnson
QB Case Keenum
LB Emmanuel Lamur
HB Jerrick McKinnon
OL Jeremiah Sirles
NT Shamar Stephen
WR Jarius Wright

Notable players we have added:

OL Tom Compton
QB Kirk Cousins
UT Sheldon Richardson
QB Trevor Siemian

How do you think the Vikings can address losing so much roster depth?

Liked:
#1 · Mar 25, 12:31 PM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

They continue to do so and losing quality depth will be exposed later in games. Yes they will replace it with young players with little experience and the holes will not be filled.
A lot of the depth they've lost also had starting experience. I understand the concept but outside looking in it almost looks like they are rebuilding just when they've got the team where they want to be.
SMH, I don't quite understand it.

Liked:
#2 · Mar 25, 12:55 PM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

I think there is some rebuilding going on. Not a total rebuild but a slight rebuild to accommoate the free agent signings and then the draft is coming up. Also there is still work to be done on the OL as well as defensive depth concerns. It's going to be interesting to see how it all comes together. 

Liked:
#3 · Mar 25, 2:46 PM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

totally agree.  Wright, Stephen, Sirles, Johnson, M. Floyd, Brock, all were contributors (often as starters) never given a real chance or developing players.  none of them represent big contracts.  i know this is a business and sometimes fans get too emotionally involved in the players they have watched but i dont apologize for that—Hey, we’re FANS!  what I don’t understand about RS is how he goes about his business.  Too many players are dealt with without regard to what they have given to the team.  Ask Sharrif Floyd this week. 

Liked:
#4 · Mar 25, 2:47 PM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"Tyr" said: While the Vikings have a strong roster, they have lost a lot of players this season. They can fill some of that void through the draft and rookie free agents and while they may be trying to stockpile some compensation picks for next year, I have some mild concerns about them being able to fill out the roster with quality & experienced players.

Notable players we have lost:

RG Joe Berger (Retired)........................................................ Tom Compton
QB Sam Bradford................................................................. Kirk Cousins
QB Teddy Bridgewater......................................................... Trevor Siemian
CB Tremaine Brock.............................................................. A soggy Tuna Sandwich?  I was seriously unimpressed with Brock
WR Michael Floyd (not expected to be re-signed).................Coley?
UT Sharrif Floyd (injuries)..................................................... Hasn't really played in how long?  Can you really call him depth?
UT Tom Johnson................................................................... Sheldon Richardson
QB Case Keenum..................................................................Sloter
LB Emmanuel Lamur.............................................................?
HB Jerrick McKinnon.............................................................Mack/Ham/?
OL Jeremiah Sirles................................................................1st Rd Pick?
NT Shamar Stephen..............................................................2nd Rd Pick?
WR Jarius Wright...................................................................?

Notable players we have added:

OL Tom Compton
QB Kirk Cousins
UT Sheldon Richardson
QB Trevor Siemian

How do you think the Vikings can address losing so much roster depth?

We still have the second and third waves of free agency and the lower rds of the draft -- Are we really that thin?

Liked:
#5 · Mar 25, 2:51 PM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

I would think Compton would be more a Sirles replacement than a Berger replacement.

Liked:
#6 · Mar 25, 3:06 PM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"Watcher" said:
@"Tyr" said: While the Vikings have a strong roster, they have lost a lot of players this season. They can fill some of that void through the draft and rookie free agents and while they may be trying to stockpile some compensation picks for next year, I have some mild concerns about them being able to fill out the roster with quality & experienced players.

Notable players we have lost:

RG Joe Berger (Retired)........................................................ Tom Compton
QB Sam Bradford................................................................. Kirk Cousins
QB Teddy Bridgewater......................................................... Trevor Siemian
CB Tremaine Brock.............................................................. A soggy Tuna Sandwich?  I was seriously unimpressed with Brock
WR Michael Floyd (not expected to be re-signed).................Coley?
UT Sharrif Floyd (injuries)..................................................... Hasn't really played in how long?  Can you really call him depth?
UT Tom Johnson................................................................... Sheldon Richardson
QB Case Keenum..................................................................Sloter
LB Emmanuel Lamur.............................................................?
HB Jerrick McKinnon.............................................................Mack/Ham/?
OL Jeremiah Sirles................................................................1st Rd Pick?
NT Shamar Stephen..............................................................2nd Rd Pick?
WR Jarius Wright...................................................................?

Notable players we have added:

OL Tom Compton
QB Kirk Cousins
UT Sheldon Richardson
QB Trevor Siemian

How do you think the Vikings can address losing so much roster depth?

We still have the second and third waves of free agency and the lower rds of the draft -- Are we really that thin?



1. RG Joe Berger - ???2. QB Sam Bradford - Kirk Cousins3. QB Teddy Bridgewater - Trevor Siemian4. CB Tremain Brock - ??? :: I agree that I wasn't very impressed with him, but between him going and Newman and Sherles still waiting to be re-signed CB is looking thin right now.5. WR Michael Floyd - WR Stacy Coley :: Seems fair that he'd get a shot at some point.6. UT Shariff Floyd - UT Sheldon Richardson :: Floyd has missed the last two seasons because of injuries, but his absence was definitely felt. A quick penetrating DT not to mention the extra depth would have been huge last season.7. UT Tom Johnson - UT Jaleel Johnson :: Maybe Jaleel finally shows some signs of life.8. QB Case Keenum - QB Kyle Sloter or draft pick :: People seem to like Sloter, but waiting to see something from him.9. LB Emmanuel Lamur - LB Eric Wilson (?) :: Coaches seem to like him.10. HB Jerrick McKinnon - ??? :: Ham is a FB and I'm not familiar with Mack Brown. He's only had a few touches in 3-years, so this maybe be a draft need.11. OL Jeremiah Sirles - OL Tom Compton12. NT Shamar Stepehen - ??? :: Richardson and Johnson seem more like 3-techniques, so a back NT even as a rotational piece would be nice to have.13. WR Jarius Wright - ???

It's quite striking to see so many experienced players not being brought back. They are definitely losing a lot of experience and while that will create opportunities for younger players like Jaleel Johnson, Stacy Cooley, and Eric Wilson, it does mean that we will have a lot of untested depth. It also makes me think that a lot of rookies and rookie free agents may make the roster this year to fill things out. They seem to be trying to get compensation picks, which is fine, but there are still certain veterans they could pursue who don't impact that formula. Kind of wonder if things will be quite until after the draft?

Liked:
#7 · Mar 25, 7:21 PM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

Sirles, Wright and Stephen were tough for me as a fan...Shariff hasn't played in how many years now? Floyd? Not sure we wont see him back. 

They needed to pay handsomely for a franchise qb and they've got: 
Diggs
Barr
Kendricks
Hunter
 
On the docket...Welcome to the NFL when you are paying a franchise QB. 
Spielman knows that people are concerned about the team’s salary cap in the coming years, but he said the team has it under control.
“ Rob Brzezinski does an outstanding job with the cap,” Spielman said. “We know we have some extensions coming up and we want to make sure that we have enough room to potentially get some extensions done coming up here in the near future.”

Liked:
#8 · Mar 25, 8:05 PM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

Liked:
#9 · Mar 25, 9:34 PM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

Not terribly concerned at this point except starting OL and backup DL.  Every year we've wondered why our draft picks aren't playing.  This year they'll get to.  We'll need 3 players from the draft to contribute. 

Liked:
#10 · Mar 26, 7:34 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

This is the time of year when players are griping about teams being cheap or favoring the new signings over "loyalty to veterans".  But in past years, the Vikings held on to players too long or gave big contracts to marginal players. Which do you really prefer?
Look at the list of "notable player in the alarmist OP. If they are notable, how many would even be known to an NFL fan who isn't devoted to the Vikings? Sam Bradford and Michael Floyd are the best known, and partly for non-positive reasons.
Net effect of this offseason, SO FAR, has been the Vikings adding 2 players under age 30 who have played in Pro Bowls, and losing a handful of guys with modest production or big question marks.
The only guys I expect to miss at all are Wright and Stephen, but Jaleel Johnson and Stacy Coley will get better opportunities with them gone. There are still good FAs available and the draft.

Liked:
#11 · Mar 26, 8:00 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

They'll continue to keep shopping for depth as remaining UFA prices come down. But they are reshaping the roster a little bit to even out their personnel before they get too heavy defensively. 2017 may have been an eye opener that you can have both a strong defense and offense if you commit the time and resources to it. 

The larger culprit is the 2016 draft class that will show its ugly head. Those are the cost controllable players that are supposed to be making a significant impact in both 2018/2019. That class was: 

1 - Treadwell 
2 - Alexander 
3 - Traded to MIA 
4 - Beavers 
5 - Kentrell Brothers 
6 - Bohringer 
6 - Morgan 
7 - Weatherly 
7- Kearse 

Liked:
#12 · Mar 26, 8:02 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"AGRforever" said: Not terribly concerned at this point except starting OL and backup DL.  Every year we've wondered why our draft picks aren't playing.  This year they'll get to.  We'll need 3 players from the draft to contribute. 


If they came back with 3 O linemen and 2 D lineman we would start to adress the depth problem given that some of them wont turn out.  I dont think there is anyway we see those numbers.
Im guessing draft 1 O linemen and 2 D linemen and try to pick up journeymen in the 2nd Fa.  

Liked:
#13 · Mar 26, 8:03 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"Watcher" said:

We still have the second and third waves of free agency and the lower rds of the draft -- Are we really that thin?




No. There are probably between 25 and 30 NFL teams who would love to have our "depth problem." It's important to have a little perspective. Yeah, it would be great to have Tom Johnson as depth, but my goodness, we just signed Sheldon Richardson and drafted a 3T last year. Broncos just traded for Jared Veldheer who's been injured both of the last two years. Smacks of a Jake Long type signing to me. We're not losing starters, we're losing players who have been upgraded. Yeah, it would be great to keep Jerrick McKinnon, but that was never in the cards because we now have Dalvin Cook and Latavius Murray. Jeremiah Sirles was good, solid depth, but we drafted Danny Isadora. We drafted him because we KNEW that Sirles wouldn't be here in 2018. We drafted Coley to replace Wright. We drafted Alexander to replace Newman.

You gotta draft well and trust your draft. It would be one thing if we were turning over valuable depth slots to rookies, but we're not. Alexander is a 3rd year player. Jaleel, Coley, Isadora, these are 2nd year players.  And next year, when Murray leaves, we'll have a 2nd year back from this draft to take his place. This kind of down-depth turnover is not unusual. It's healthy.

Liked:
#14 · Mar 26, 8:41 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"Geoff Nichols" said: They'll continue to keep shopping for depth as remaining UFA prices come down. But they are reshaping the roster a little bit to even out their personnel before they get too heavy defensively. 2017 may have been an eye opener that you can have both a strong defense and offense if you commit the time and resources to it. 

The larger culprit is the 2016 draft class that will show its ugly head. Those are the cost controllable players that are supposed to be making a significant impact in both 2018/2019. That class was: 

1 - Treadwell 
2 - Alexander 
3 - Traded to MIA 
4 - Beavers 
5 - Kentrell Brothers 
6 - Bohringer 
6 - Morgan 
7 - Weatherly 
7- Kearse 


Really great and important observation about that draft. Also a reminder that counting on the draft is dicey. Plenty of people saying we can draft a starting OL at #30 - but we couldn't find a productive WR at #23.
Any explanation why 2016 has been, to date, such a poor draft? Just a matter of "lucky in 2015, unlucky in 2016" or were different people involved?

Liked:
#15 · Mar 26, 10:24 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"Geoff Nichols" said: They'll continue to keep shopping for depth as remaining UFA prices come down. But they are reshaping the roster a little bit to even out their personnel before they get too heavy defensively. 2017 may have been an eye opener that you can have both a strong defense and offense if you commit the time and resources to it. 

The larger culprit is the 2016 draft class that will show its ugly head. Those are the cost controllable players that are supposed to be making a significant impact in both 2018/2019. That class was: 

1 - Treadwell 
2 - Alexander 
3 - Traded to MIA 
4 - Beavers 
5 - Kentrell Brothers 
6 - Bohringer 
6 - Morgan 
7 - Weatherly 
7- Kearse 


And that was coming off a 2015 season where we went 11-5 and thinking all our holes were filled.  Hopefully we don't swing and miss this year lol because that draft was UGLY with a capital Sarah Jessica Parker

Liked:
#16 · Mar 26, 10:54 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"Jor-El" said:
@"Geoff Nichols" said: They'll continue to keep shopping for depth as remaining UFA prices come down. But they are reshaping the roster a little bit to even out their personnel before they get too heavy defensively. 2017 may have been an eye opener that you can have both a strong defense and offense if you commit the time and resources to it. 

The larger culprit is the 2016 draft class that will show its ugly head. Those are the cost controllable players that are supposed to be making a significant impact in both 2018/2019. That class was: 

1 - Treadwell 
2 - Alexander 
3 - Traded to MIA 
4 - Beavers 
5 - Kentrell Brothers 
6 - Bohringer 
6 - Morgan 
7 - Weatherly 
7- Kearse 


Really great and important observation about that draft. Also a reminder that counting on the draft is dicey. Plenty of people saying we can draft a starting OL at #30 - but we couldn't find a productive WR at #23.
Any explanation why 2016 has been, to date, such a poor draft? Just a matter of "lucky in 2015, unlucky in 2016" or were different people involved?



A truly dreadful, dud of a draft...Cant afford many of those. 

Liked:
#17 · Mar 27, 6:23 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

Not having players develop in a draft class has a bigger long term impact than missing on a high pick.  It looks like the 16 class has left us thin, unless Alexander keeps improving and Treadwell breaks out with a different QB.  Morgan and Kearse have both had moments and can contribute.

Liked:
#18 · Mar 27, 7:15 AM
Log in to reply.

Edit Post (mod action — author will see a notice)

Warn Poster

Suspend User (3 days)

The user will be suspended for 3 days and will receive an email with the reason and information about how to appeal.

Forum The Longship Roster Depth
Return to top ↑

Welcome to VikeFans!

Welcome back, Skol fans! This is our new home. Log in with your username or email and your existing password.


Be sure to check out the How To's and Questions forum for guides on getting around the new site, and use the Help Request forum if you run into anything that you need help with. Skol!