Tony Romo as broadcaster....refreshing (IMO)
Ok...just watched an NFLN pre game thing where they were talking to Romo.
havent heard him do a game, but the guy knows his chit.
anyone have an opinion on Romo as color analyst? Heard him? Thoughts?
what a difference from Michael Irvin's yammering and stammering
I've heard people complain that he talks too much... and maybe there's a little bit to that. Sometimes less is better. But, overall, I actually DO enjoy his commentary. He really does know his stuff. I've kinda wondered, though... if the "less informed" (i.e. "casual"?) fans feel like he talks over their heads. He speaks football... but not every fan understands that language. For what it's worth, though, I enjoy him.
@"pumpf" said: I've heard people complain that he talks too much... and maybe there's a little bit to that. Sometimes less is better. But, overall, I actually DO enjoy his commentary. He really does know his stuff. I've kinda wondered, though... if the "less informed" (i.e. "casual"?) fans feel like he talks over their heads. He speaks football... but not every fan understands that language. For what it's worth, though, I enjoy him.That sums it up for me completely...Know's his s hit, probably over the head of most including me. He's a nice change of pace that could end-up really good in the booth over time.
I think he's the best out there right now. No bias whatsoever, knowledgeable, dynamic, and energetic.
it won't take long for the network and media types to beat all the good out of him....
Put me in the "does he get paid by the word category?"... My first impression was very favorable... By the second quarter of the first game I was wishing he would STFU...
@"BarrNone55" said: Put me in the "does he get paid by the word category?"... My first impression was very favorable... By the second quarter of the first game I was wishing he would STFU...So much this....
But I also think that color commentators are useless. To quote a Richard Jeni bit... Your watching it on TV all the guy has to say is.. "Did you see that? So did I."
I think Tony does a good job. He's got PLENTY of enthusiasm, that's for sure....which of course can get to be a little too much but I've seen several games he's done now and I do love how he shares his knowledge of the game.
I guarantee you the network is telling Romo to talk more. They've gotten the early reviews on him and they are very positive, so in their world, more is better. 'Keep talking, Tony.....keep up the chatter. Viewers love you!'. Typical saturation move by the TV network. They can't leave a good thing alone.
Here's an article on him...
https://www.si.com/tech-media/2017/10/29/tony-romo-journey-cbs-analyst
I don't have a strong opinion on anybody who dislikes him, but... I absolutely love him as a commentator. Probably an age thing. Which is funny, because I'm usually the opposite when it comes to that millenial bullshit.
I like the football knowledge, but he just seems like such a likable guy. He's not polished, but will get there. But I don't really care.
@"Bezerker88" said:@"BarrNone55" said: Put me in the "does he get paid by the word category?"... My first impression was very favorable... By the second quarter of the first game I was wishing he would STFU... So much this....But I also think that color commentators are useless. To quote a Richard Jeni bit... Your watching it on TV all the guy has to say is.. "Did you see that? So did I."
A good color commentator should be saying, "Did you see that? So did everyone, but what you might not have seen is this." IOW, tell us about the subtle things we may have missed while looking at the main action.
There's times I forget its Tony...his voice goes at least 2 octaves highr as he get's more riled up. He's ok by me.
He's actually tolerable today...maybe he got decaf...
He's is better than most but definitely could talk a tad less.
Just said Marcus Peters make Deion Sanders look like a willing tackler! Truth in advertising.
Considering there are so many crappy commentators that make stupid jokes or don't know what the hell they are talking about, he sticks out in a good way. He doesn't his homework and knows his stuff. I really enjoy listening to him. I like his energy and his insight.
@"A1Janitor" said: I like him. But I like Chris Collinsworth too.Same here.
Edit Post (mod action — author will see a notice)
Warn Poster
Suspend User (3 days)
The user will be suspended for 3 days and will receive an email with the reason and information about how to appeal.