Wentz Midseason MVP?
Carson Wentz - QB - EaglesCarson Wentz completed 17-of-25 passes for 268 yards, four touchdowns, and one interception in the Eagles' 34-24, Week 7 win over the Redskins on Monday night.
Wentz now leads the league with 17 passing touchdowns, two more than Tom Brady, Alex Smith, and Deshaun Watson. After not having a single three-touchdown passing game in his first 20 career starts, Wentz has accomplished the feat in back-to-back-to-back weeks, with 11 touchdown passes total in that span. He's put himself squarely in the MVP conversation as the quarterback on the league's best team. Wentz's night started inauspiciously with an interception on the opening drive, but it was all good from there. His first score was a 64-yard bomb to rookie Mack Hollins, the second a flat route to Zach Ertz near the goal line, the third a short fade to Corey Clement, and the fourth a laser strike to Nelson Agholor. Wentz gets another dream matchup next week at home against a hapless 49ers defense. Wentz is a legit QB1 moving forward.
Hard to argue against him...kid is en fuego...
This won't help...
Wentz looks really good, like a veteran. Smooth and poised. Great NFL QB body and athleticism. Excellent arm. Just what you'd want at the position.
There seems to be an uptick in good, young talent at the position...Wentz, Goff, Watson, Prescott...we need to tap into that vein next season...
Matchup wise, Eagles Vs Vikings could be a very good one. I would imagine the gameplan would be similar to the one deployed vs Green Bay.
Harrison vs Ertz (two of the best at their position)
Rhodes vs Jeffery (Rhodes closed in a familar battle)
Barr spying on Wentz (Not Rodgers yet but close in ability)
Their rushing attack vs our run D (we do well vs Big Backs like Blount)
the loss of Peters will be huge as the Philly OL looks suspect which is why we would have an advantage versus their O. Question would be, can our O be healthy enough to get past their defense. The development or strong play of Waynes or Mac Man could be the deciding factor as they could cancel out any potential offense they could have
Come late January, we could find out
@"BarrNone55" said: There seems to be an uptick in good, young talent at the position...Wentz, Goff, Watson, Prescott...we need to tap into that vein next season...
Good for the Eagles for the move. Goff and Prescott are the most surprising to me...
NFL is going to need a new group of young guns. Brady is 40 and while Rogers is only 33, that aint a spring chicken in nfl years.
Too bad there isn't a Viking among that group, always the bridesmaids when it comes to qb's.
Rogers turns 34 in about a month(Dec 2). Hey, every year counts.
@"Skodin" said: Matchup wise, Eagles Vs Vikings could be a very good one. I would imagine the gameplan would be similar to the one deployed vs Green Bay.Harrison vs Ertz (two of the best at their position)
Rhodes vs Jeffery (Rhodes closed in a familar battle)
Barr spying on Wentz (Not Rodgers yet but close in ability)
Their rushing attack vs our run D (we do well vs Big Backs like Blount)the loss of Peters will be huge as the Philly OL looks suspect which is why we would have an advantage versus their O. Question would be, can our O be healthy enough to get past their defense. The development or strong play of Waynes or Mac Man could be the deciding factor as they could cancel out any potential offense they could have
Come late January, we could find out
this is what I am thinking of when I say we need to see what Teddy can do. I dont see anyway that Case can lead the team over a quality opponent. this run weve been on is fun and all, but lets be honest in saying we havent really faced much in terms of quality opponents and the 1 that we did face was quickly without their starting QB. We are going to need a real QB to beat quality balanced teams. Hell even the Redskins IMO are going to be a tough out if we dont have more of a passing game.
@"JimmyinSD" said:@"Skodin" said: Matchup wise, Eagles Vs Vikings could be a very good one. I would imagine the gameplan would be similar to the one deployed vs Green Bay.Harrison vs Ertz (two of the best at their position)
Rhodes vs Jeffery (Rhodes closed in a familar battle)
Barr spying on Wentz (Not Rodgers yet but close in ability)
Their rushing attack vs our run D (we do well vs Big Backs like Blount)the loss of Peters will be huge as the Philly OL looks suspect which is why we would have an advantage versus their O. Question would be, can our O be healthy enough to get past their defense. The development or strong play of Waynes or Mac Man could be the deciding factor as they could cancel out any potential offense they could have
Come late January, we could find out
this is what I am thinking of when I say we need to see what Teddy can do. I dont see anyway that Case can lead the team over a quality opponent. this run weve been on is fun and all, but lets be honest in saying we havent really faced much in terms of quality opponents and the 1 that we did face was quickly without their starting QB. We are going to need a real QB to beat quality balanced teams. Hell even the Redskins IMO are going to be a tough out if we dont have more of a passing game.
Agree, until I see Case making multiple reads and hitting second and maybe third choices with accuracy I see a decent backup QB. But he can improve in the system so I am holding out hope. I will say that I did not see much improvement from his full start GB game to the Ravens game. We will need big improvement from him, Teddy or Sam back to be playoff run contenders - IMO.Also, the lack of sacks and interceptions benefit from Case going first read or throw away/run. If he took the time for more reads those stats would also go up in a negative way but again when we play better teams he is going to have to play better. Our Defense is only going to carry so far.
@"StickyBun" said: Wentz looks really good, like a veteran. Smooth and poised. Great NFL QB body and athleticism. Excellent arm. Just what you'd want at the position.
Yup. At least at QB. Fournette's having an awesome year too...
@"Ralphie" said:@"StickyBun" said: Wentz looks really good, like a veteran. Smooth and poised. Great NFL QB body and athleticism. Excellent arm. Just what you'd want at the position.Yup. At least at QB. Fournette's having an awesome year too...
If you're referring to MVP, at this point I'd put Fournette more in the running for Off. Rookie of the Year. Although, missing too much time to injury could hurt his chances. I'd say he's in the race with Watson and Hunt as it is right now. It sucks for Dalvin since he appeared to be on a path to be in it too.
@"CLOBIMON" said:@"Ralphie" said:@"StickyBun" said: Wentz looks really good, like a veteran. Smooth and poised. Great NFL QB body and athleticism. Excellent arm. Just what you'd want at the position.Yup. At least at QB. Fournette's having an awesome year too...
If you're referring to MVP, at this point I'd put Fournette more in the running for Off. Rookie of the Year. Although, missing too much time to injury could hurt his chances. I'd say he's in the race with Watson and Hunt as it is right now. It sucks for Dalvin since he appeared to be on a path to be in it too.Agreed. ROTY is more likely for Fournette. He's just missed last week and with a bye should be back.
But I posted a week or so ago, I've seen Carson play a couple of games now and he just doesn't look like a 2 season starter. Yeah, he's missing a few reads, but the kid is a winner. Philly actually got it right at QB this time.
@"Ralphie" said: he just doesn't look like a 2 season starter. Yeah, he's missing a few reads, but the kid is a winner. Philly actually got it right at QB this time.
I am a bit surprised how well he's doing this quickly. At the same time though, it did feel like a lot of the draft pundits were wanting to brush him off due to the level he played at, despite leading the best of the best in FCS. I do think most of that was early, before they'd watched tape or seen his combine & workouts.
Being in the area I usually watch a lot of the NDSU games and I saw him as
better than Brock Jensen, but I wasn't so sure how much better. Like
Wentz, Jensen was a tough gamer that brought it all as well, especially
in big games. Unlike Wentz though, he couldn't even earn an NFL practice squad spot or stay on a CFL roster. So I guess teams and scouts get it right at least some of the time.
@"JimmyinSD" said:@"Skodin" said: Matchup wise, Eagles Vs Vikings could be a very good one. I would imagine the gameplan would be similar to the one deployed vs Green Bay.Harrison vs Ertz (two of the best at their position)
Rhodes vs Jeffery (Rhodes closed in a familar battle)
Barr spying on Wentz (Not Rodgers yet but close in ability)
Their rushing attack vs our run D (we do well vs Big Backs like Blount)the loss of Peters will be huge as the Philly OL looks suspect which is why we would have an advantage versus their O. Question would be, can our O be healthy enough to get past their defense. The development or strong play of Waynes or Mac Man could be the deciding factor as they could cancel out any potential offense they could have
Come late January, we could find out
this is what I am thinking of when I say we need to see what Teddy can do. I dont see anyway that Case can lead the team over a quality opponent. this run weve been on is fun and all, but lets be honest in saying we havent really faced much in terms of quality opponents and the 1 that we did face was quickly without their starting QB. We are going to need a real QB to beat quality balanced teams. Hell even the Redskins IMO are going to be a tough out if we dont have more of a passing game.
well I disagre that Case can't lead us over a quality opponent. He can, but and has IMO, but not at the level we need to make a playoff run. He is limited, but has done well limiting his mistakes. Detroit was a tough loss and much of that was because of poor QB play. He can win, but as we saw against Baltimore, our D has to play tough and the special teams have to pick up the slack. Would be nice to have the offense carry the load more often tho.
@"greediron" said:@"JimmyinSD" said:@"Skodin" said: Matchup wise, Eagles Vs Vikings could be a very good one. I would imagine the gameplan would be similar to the one deployed vs Green Bay.Harrison vs Ertz (two of the best at their position)
Rhodes vs Jeffery (Rhodes closed in a familar battle)
Barr spying on Wentz (Not Rodgers yet but close in ability)
Their rushing attack vs our run D (we do well vs Big Backs like Blount)the loss of Peters will be huge as the Philly OL looks suspect which is why we would have an advantage versus their O. Question would be, can our O be healthy enough to get past their defense. The development or strong play of Waynes or Mac Man could be the deciding factor as they could cancel out any potential offense they could have
Come late January, we could find out
this is what I am thinking of when I say we need to see what Teddy can do. I dont see anyway that Case can lead the team over a quality opponent. this run weve been on is fun and all, but lets be honest in saying we havent really faced much in terms of quality opponents and the 1 that we did face was quickly without their starting QB. We are going to need a real QB to beat quality balanced teams. Hell even the Redskins IMO are going to be a tough out if we dont have more of a passing game.
well I disagre that Case can't lead us over a quality opponent. He can, but and has IMO, but not at the level we need to make a playoff run. He is limited, but has done well limiting his mistakes. Detroit was a tough loss and much of that was because of poor QB play. He can win, but as we saw against Baltimore, our D has to play tough and the special teams have to pick up the slack. Would be nice to have the offense carry the load more often tho.
He has done very little the last 3 weeks to contribute to the wins. That won't fly the last 8 weeks or in the playoffs.
I'd say Wentz has to seriously considered a MVP candidate. He can to it all and is doing it all. He throws deep, short, medium, and be so illusive to the pass rush. It's unbelievable the plays he's making.
I live in Fargo so I watched quite of bit of him at NDSU. No way did I predict he'd be this good this soon. He's just a very talented young guy who works his ass off to be great. It's working too.
I think his character and personality are going to serve him well also. He seems like a guy that is tough to hate... perhaps not unlike another upper-midwest guy, Thielen, or even Teddy. He doesn't appear to have that cocky, douchebag, self-entitled air to him that we see often from the upper echelon at the position.
@"CLOBIMON" said: I think his character and personality are going to serve him well also. He seems like a guy that is tough to hate... perhaps not unlike another upper-midwest guy, Thielen, or even Teddy. He doesn't appear to have that cocky, douchebag, self-entitled air to him that we see often from the upper echelon at the position.
He's in Philly now... I am sure it will rub off on him eventually.
@"JimmyinSD" said:@"CLOBIMON" said: I think his character and personality are going to serve him well also. He seems like a guy that is tough to hate... perhaps not unlike another upper-midwest guy, Thielen, or even Teddy. He doesn't appear to have that cocky, douchebag, self-entitled air to him that we see often from the upper echelon at the position.
He's in Philly now... I am sure it will rub off on him eventually.
Wentz will throw the game as a Life long Viking fan :)Lived in Philly and at the time been to about 15 Eagles Games.
Now live 2 hours from philly and been to about 4 Eagles games at the Link.
Worst fans ever and can back that up over and over again. Partied with them in South Philly when I lived there we looked for trouble and fights after drinking at 8 am in the morning and playing tackle football about 10 minutes from the stadium at 30 years old (yeah I know???) By the time we got to the game....whatever..this was right before the court system in the stadium and the fans have not become better.
Just sat by my fire pit talking to my neighbor who made the trip to Philly last night for MNF..said he never say worst fans ever!
@"minny65" said:@"JimmyinSD" said:@"CLOBIMON" said: I think his character and personality are going to serve him well also. He seems like a guy that is tough to hate... perhaps not unlike another upper-midwest guy, Thielen, or even Teddy. He doesn't appear to have that cocky, douchebag, self-entitled air to him that we see often from the upper echelon at the position.
He's in Philly now... I am sure it will rub off on him eventually.
Wentz will throw the game as a Life long Viking fan :)Lived in Philly and at the time been to about 15 Eagles Games.
Now live 2 hours from philly and been to about 4 Eagles games at the Link.
Worst fans ever and can back that up over and over again. Partied with them in South Philly when I lived there we looked for trouble and fights after drinking at 8 am in the morning and playing tackle football about 10 minutes from the stadium at 30 years old (yeah I know???) By the time we got to the game....whatever..this was right before the court system in the stadium and the fans have not become better.
Just sat by my fire pit talking to my neighbor who made the trip to Philly last night for MNF..said he never say worst fans ever!
Philly...great sandwich, crappy sports fans.
@"JimmyinSD" He has done very little the last 3 weeks to contribute to the wins. That won't fly the last 8 weeks or in the playoffs.
He's done enough the last 3 weeks...The Ravens D is ranked pretty good.
you compare Case & Teddy's completion percentage and it is almost exactly the same. 63/64%
Teddy needs to do better than the 33.9 QB rating he had in his playoff appearance.
I hope Teddy or Sam is the answer and I would love to see Teddy do great coming back from that injury. But there still is some questions...
edit: corrected some
Edit Post (mod action — author will see a notice)
Warn Poster
Suspend User (3 days)
The user will be suspended for 3 days and will receive an email with the reason and information about how to appeal.