Reid On The QB Class

No context needed.

— Dashawn @Tjames1224 Oct 18, 2026

𝕏 X / Twitter — Dashawn @Tjames1224

No context needed.

View on X

Absolutely brutal.

Manning doesn't look good, zero doubt about it. And I think its getting into his head now....I'm seeing some yips on easy throws.

StickierBuns wrote:

As a Michigan fan, it’s infuriating watching them trot out Underwood each week, disgustingly horrible. Carr is no savior, but he can function at the position and get incrementally better. The multi-million dollar swing on him was an utter failure, move the F on. It’s like the program has been on a coke bender since the national championship with decisions. 🙄😡

Michigan seemed to respond to Carr. I think that’s big. Didn’t even flip over to this game momentarily which shows the state of both programs at the moment.

JustInTime wrote:

Michigan seemed to respond to Carr. I think that’s big. Didn’t even flip over to this game momentarily which shows the state of both programs at the moment.

Oh the team loves him, but he's a true freshman. All this playing time that he'll now be getting will help a ton next year.

Yep, Michigan football with Underwood is bad and boring ball. I can't watch it for a whole game and I'm a fan. 🤮 I've got friends who are Miami fans so I'm living through them right now for CFB.

StickierBuns wrote:

Oh the team loves him, but he's a true freshman. All this playing time that he'll now be getting will help a ton next year.
Yep, Michigan football with Underwood is bad and boring ball. I can't watch it for a whole game and I'm a fan. 🤮 I've got friends who are Miami fans so I'm living through them right now for CFB.

Miami has been fun. I've been a Miami and ACC fan for much of my life, I think you and I have talked about this last season. I have been super busy with work so haven't tuned in as much as I would like. I am also a Michigan fan. I like to see them win. Underwood is notoriously bad. You see him try and go through his progressions, and it somehow ends up in another county.

a few weeks ago I was looking at Mensah and Mestemaker as targets I liked outside the top 10.  I actually like Mestemaker a little more as a NFL QB, but thought we would be happy to get on of the 2.  Sadly now they are the top 2 QB prospects and the preseason darlings are falling aside to include rumblings of Manning not even coming out.  

Carr could be a possibility, I am out on Chambliss.  Manning should enter the draft and go to a better NFL team and get a season of coaching vs another year of college play.

Metermaker is the one I am liking. I am not a scout and as the days go by I am liking him more. So wanna hear what you guys think

mblack wrote:

Metermaker is the one I am liking. I am not a scout and as the days go by I am liking him more. So wanna hear what you guys think

He’s quickly becoming the consensus QB1. Definitely needs another year but wouldn’t be surprised if he declares.

If we can’t afford Redmond.

The two Michigan CBs made money today.

A little uneven for the game, but that TD run was something.

Arch and Texas walking over Ole Miss. Chambliss is struggling.