Forum › The Longship › Madden QB rankings

Madden QB rankings

Vikergirl
Vikergirl
Joined May 2013
2,907 posts
Rep: 678

You're only given a little spark of madness. You mustn't lose it. — Robin Williams

Liked:
#1 · Jul 22, 6:44 PM
DE
deleted_user
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

Liked:
#2 · Jul 22, 6:45 PM
DE
deleted_user
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

I would go Mahomes, Allen, Herbert, Burrow, Brady (I refuse to put the whiny one on any list).  Prescott and the rest of the Cowboys are consistently overrated, pretty amazing for a bunch of guys who have never done anything. 

Liked:
#3 · Jul 23, 9:16 AM
DE
deleted_user
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

I think Herbert and Wilson should be above Prescott. Also, not convinced Stafford is top 10. 

Liked:
#4 · Jul 23, 11:47 AM
DE
deleted_user
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

Herbert, Wilson, Dak, Stafford and Cousins should all be in that 87-89 range. Cousins rating is laughable. Talk about knowing zip about playing QB. Only in this bizarro world does the guy with the 4th highest passer rating in the league get rated so low. Lamar Jackson belongs nowhere near a top 10 list.

Liked:
#5 · Jul 23, 1:01 PM
DE
deleted_user
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"Havoc1649" said: Herbert, Wilson, Dak, Stafford and Cousins should all be in that 87-89 range. Cousins rating is laughable. Talk about knowing zip about playing QB. Only in this bizarro world does the guy with the 4th highest passer rating in the league get rated so low. Lamar Jackson belongs nowhere near a top 10 list.
How low is too low?  A lot of lists have him ranked middle of the pack.
Liked:
#6 · Jul 25, 7:59 AM
DE
deleted_user
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"medaille" said:
@"Havoc1649" said: Herbert, Wilson, Dak, Stafford and Cousins should all be in that 87-89 range. Cousins rating is laughable. Talk about knowing zip about playing QB. Only in this bizarro world does the guy with the 4th highest passer rating in the league get rated so low. Lamar Jackson belongs nowhere near a top 10 list.
How low is too low?  A lot of lists have him ranked middle of the pack.
A lot of those lists are indefensible. One must ignore all objective statistical measure as well as all game tape to deduce that Cousins falls in the middle of the pack. For whatever reason, Cousins evokes considerable emotion in people, overriding the reality that he performs at a very high level. 
Liked:
#7 · Jul 26, 2:17 AM
DE
deleted_user
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"Havoc1649" said:
@"medaille" said:
@"Havoc1649" said: Herbert, Wilson, Dak, Stafford and Cousins should all be in that 87-89 range. Cousins rating is laughable. Talk about knowing zip about playing QB. Only in this bizarro world does the guy with the 4th highest passer rating in the league get rated so low. Lamar Jackson belongs nowhere near a top 10 list.
How low is too low?  A lot of lists have him ranked middle of the pack.
A lot of those lists are indefensible. One must ignore all objective statistical measure as well as all game tape to deduce that Cousins falls in the middle of the pack. For whatever reason, Cousins evokes considerable emotion in people, overriding the reality that he performs at a very high level. 
How low is too low?  What’s your line for a ranking list to be ridiculous?  Most lists put him in the 10-20 range.  Is that “indefensible”?  Do you find almost all ranking lists indefensible?
Liked:
#8 · Jul 26, 8:00 AM
Log in to reply.

Edit Post (mod action — author will see a notice)

Warn Poster

Suspend User (3 days)

The user will be suspended for 3 days and will receive an email with the reason and information about how to appeal.

Forum › The Longship › Madden QB rankings
Return to top ↑

Welcome to VikeFans!

Welcome back, Skol fans! This is our new home. Log in with your username or email and your existing password.


Be sure to check out the How To's and Questions forum for guides on getting around the new site, and use the Help Request forum if you run into anything that you need help with. Skol!