Forum The Longship 2022 Draft Rankings—Underrated/Overrated

2022 Draft Rankings—Underrated/Overrated

MaroonBells
Joined Jan 2014
4,321 posts
Rep: 4,501

PREDICTION
This draft will break a record for trades. Vikings will trade down and take Trent McDuffie. I want them to trade down big, get a 1st next year, and take Kaiir Elam. I’ve tried calling but Rick blocked my number in 2014. 
WHAT AM I MISSING
Kenny Pickett, QB - He’s Cousins 2.0. Not quite the arm strength, but accurate and much more mobile
RANKINGS

Corners:

  1. Ahmad Gardner - Worry about his strength and in off coverage, big upside though
  2. Derek Stingley Jr - Classic boom or bust. If Daronte signs off, I’ll like him more.
  3. Trent McDuffie - Best all around corner in the draft. But upside is limited.
  4. Kaiir Elam - Terrific in coverage, tackling problem maybe a little overstated
  5. Andrew Booth, Jr - best open field tackler, but SO many injuries
Overrated: Ahmad Gardner - Great in press, Less great in off
Underrated: Coby Bryant - Poor man’s McDuffie
Edge:
  1. Aiden Hutchinson - What’s not to like?
  2. Travon Walker - Held back at Georgia, but built to attack
  3. Jermaine Johnson - He belongs in top 10
  4. Kayvon Thibodeaux - Probably UNDERrrated now
  5. Drake Jackson - Early concerns about character might have been overblown
Overrated: George Karloftis - Doesn’t belong in conversation with those around him
Underrated: Josh Paschal
Safeties

  1. Kyle Hamilton - Love his instincts
  2. Lewis Cine - One dimensional? Haven’t decided, but he hits like a truck
  3. Nick Cross - HWS
Overrated: Dax Hill - I think he’s a corner Underrated: Nick Cross - Piece of clay WR:
  1. Chris Olave - Nice feet, routes, more experience than Wilson
  2. Garrett Wilson - Love receivers like this. Versatile, YAC, great feet and routes
  3. Jameson Williams - Small, fragile, hurt and will drop some balls, but the most explosive receiver in the draft
  4. George Pickens - Character red flags, but the best WR I watched
  5. Christian Watson - HWS is enticing
Overrated: Drake London - Couldn’t separate in college, how will he in the NFL? Underrated: Wan’Dale Robinson - Electric ILB:
  1. Nakobe Dean - Undersized but rangy, instinctive and smart
  2. Devin Lloyd - Love him. Just like Dean a little more
  3. Christian Harris - Athlete, can cover
  4. Channing Tindall - Better pro than college player
  5. Quay Walker - Better college than pro player
Overrated: Troy Anderson - My alma mater, but what do you do with him? Underrated: Channing Tindall DL:
  1. Jordan Davis - Will only play half your snaps, but give you Vita Vea when he does
  2. Logan Hall - My picks as most underrated player in the draft
  3. Devonte Wyatt - No character issues, he’s #1
  4. Travis Jones - Best football ahead of him
  5. Phidarian Mathis - Limited but productive and high motor
Overrated: Perrion Winfrey - Too much baggage Underrated: Eyioma Uwazurike, Eric Johnson QBs:
  1. Kenny Pickett - Cousins 2.0 with speed
  2. Malik Willis - Lamar Jackson 2.0 or an utter failure. Your guess as good as mine
Overrated: All the rest Underrated: Kenny Pickett OTHERS UNDERRATED Trent McDuffie, CB - Best CB I watched, coverage and character next level Kaiir Elam, CB - If he could tackle he’d be the 2nd CB after Sauce Spencer Burford, G/T - Late round G/T with long arms, good feet and was a 4-star recruit. Big Senior Bowl. Sean Rhyan, IOL - Rare OL with power and feet who can played each position Eyioma Uwazurike - Ultra versatile NT/DT/DE who’s best football is ahead of him OTHERS OVERRATED Carson Strong - He’ll be drafted but shouldn’t be Matt Corrall - The polar opposite of Cousins. But too far to the other side. David Ojabo, Edge - All athlete. Now an achilles. Where’s the Excedrin? Daxton Hill, S - Good, but should not be above Cine IMO Perrion Winfrey, Edge - Too much baggage Drake London, WR - My only real cat at the TV pick Desmond Ritter, QB  - There’s something there, but it never comes together

“A gentleman is someone who can play the accordion, but doesn't." - Tom Waits

Liked:
#1 · Apr 28, 5:01 PM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

Would love to see Stingley, Hamilton or Davis at 12.

Would love to move for Dean or Quay Walker with 2nd.

Not really a fan of McDuffie.

Liked:
#2 · Apr 28, 5:34 PM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"Rigby" said:

Not really a fan of McDuffie.


You're certainly not the only one. Vikings twitter hates young T-Mac. It's just weird to me. I don't know how anyone can watch this guy's tape, youtube, whatever and go, "wow...sure don't like that guy." 

Liked:
#3 · Apr 28, 6:14 PM
Log in to reply.

Edit Post (mod action — author will see a notice)

Warn Poster

Suspend User (3 days)

The user will be suspended for 3 days and will receive an email with the reason and information about how to appeal.

Forum The Longship 2022 Draft Rankings—Underrated/Overrated
Return to top ↑

Welcome to VikeFans!

Welcome back, Skol fans! This is our new home. Log in with your username or email and your existing password.


Be sure to check out the How To's and Questions forum for guides on getting around the new site, and use the Help Request forum if you run into anything that you need help with. Skol!