Forum The Longship Giving up on the #1 overall pick in a Draft?

Giving up on the #1 overall pick in a Draft?

StickierBuns
Joined May 2013
8,227 posts
Rep: 88
Liked:
#1 · Mar 16, 6:09 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

Wait. Drafting a QB #1 overall didn't solve all of the Browns issues?

GTFO.

Liked:
#2 · Mar 16, 6:13 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

History of #1 overall....

Trevor, Burrow, Murray, Baker, Goff, Winston, Luck, Cam, Bradford, Stafford, Jamarcus, Alex Smith....all players 37 or younger and so should still be playing. 

Liked:
#3 · Mar 16, 6:24 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"StickyBun" said: https://twitter.com/ByKimberleyA/status/1504062182748794881

Same old adage applies to politicians too

Liked:
#4 · Mar 16, 6:25 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
Liked:
#5 · Mar 16, 6:44 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

Baker and Matt Ryan might be the next QB moves. Getcha popcorn ready.

Liked:
#6 · Mar 16, 6:49 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"JustinTime18™" said: Baker and Matt Ryan might be the next QB moves. Getcha popcorn ready.
Ryan is going to be 37 years old in May. 
Liked:
#7 · Mar 16, 6:51 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

https://www.si.com/nfl/2022/03/16/cleveland-browns-baker-mayfield-point-of-no-return

Liked:
#8 · Mar 16, 7:02 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

Pretty stupid move by the Browns if they don’t already have something in place with Watson. 
Personally, I’d have been really quiet of the Watson front. Mayfield had a rough year, but he had a torn up shoulder and was sacked a ton. Sometimes seasons go like that. In 2020 he had a really nice year.

Not saying he’s going to be like him, but this feels like when Drew Brees wasn’t good enough. 

Liked:
#9 · Mar 16, 7:14 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"JustinTime18™" said: Wait. Drafting a QB #1 overall didn't solve all of the Browns issues?

GTFO.


So instead, they "might" try and get the 12th pick of the 2017 draft - Watson.  Supposedly we dabbled with some interest and a ton of teams with and without a QB are/should be interested in Watson.  He would be an upgrade for about 25+ teams.  

Some Irony if the Browns pursue Watson:

"The Texans traded up to select Watson with the Browns #12 pick in the 2017 draft.  The Browns got Texans 1st round pick for 2018, which ended up being #1 and selected Mayfield:
"The Texans traded up in the draft to select Clemson’s Deshaun Watson with pick No. 12.
Houston dealt with the Browns to select Watson as their next franchise quarterback, after dealing Brock Osweiler to Cleveland earlier this year.
The Browns acquired pick No. 25 (selected Jabrill Peppers) and Houston’s 2018 first-rounder in the deal (ended up being #1 Mayfield). 

Liked:
#10 · Mar 16, 7:15 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"minny65" said:
@"JustinTime18™" said: Wait. Drafting a QB #1 overall didn't solve all of the Browns issues?

GTFO.


So instead, they "might" try and get the 12th pick of the 2017 draft - Watson.  Supposedly we dabbled with some interest and a ton of teams with and without a QB are/should be interested in Watson.  He would be an upgrade for about 25+ teams.  

Some Irony if the Browns pursue Watson:

"The Texans traded up to select Watson with the Browns #12 pick in the 2017 draft.  The Browns got Texans 1st round pick for 2018, which ended up being #1 and selected Mayfield:
"The Texans traded up in the draft to select Clemson’s Deshaun Watson with pick No. 12.
Houston dealt with the Browns to select Watson as their next franchise quarterback, after dealing Brock Osweiler to Cleveland earlier this year.
The Browns acquired pick No. 25 (selected Jabrill Peppers) and Houston’s 2018 first-rounder in the deal (ended up being #1 Mayfield). 



Be careful about saying he's an upgrade for that many teams as his career record is only 28-25, and 1-2 in the playoffs. As we know, this board uses record as it's main determining factor for QB's

Liked:
#11 · Mar 16, 7:28 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"Hawkvike25" said:
@"minny65" said:
@"JustinTime18™" said: Wait. Drafting a QB #1 overall didn't solve all of the Browns issues?

GTFO.


So instead, they "might" try and get the 12th pick of the 2017 draft - Watson.  Supposedly we dabbled with some interest and a ton of teams with and without a QB are/should be interested in Watson.  He would be an upgrade for about 25+ teams.  

Some Irony if the Browns pursue Watson:

"The Texans traded up to select Watson with the Browns #12 pick in the 2017 draft.  The Browns got Texans 1st round pick for 2018, which ended up being #1 and selected Mayfield:
"The Texans traded up in the draft to select Clemson’s Deshaun Watson with pick No. 12.
Houston dealt with the Browns to select Watson as their next franchise quarterback, after dealing Brock Osweiler to Cleveland earlier this year.
The Browns acquired pick No. 25 (selected Jabrill Peppers) and Houston’s 2018 first-rounder in the deal (ended up being #1 Mayfield). 



Be careful about saying he's an upgrade for that many teams as his career record is only 28-25, and 1-2 in the playoffs. As we know, this board uses record as it's main determining factor for QB's


Not me, but I think I see 1 or 2 posters using W/L as a big part of an argument to move away from Kirk.  All stats can be very deceiving and twisted for an argument.  There are QB's whose stats (including wins) benefitted from having great surround - Aikman, Bradshaw come to mind quickly.  Thier are also QB's who put up poor stats but still won (Dilfer mostly comes to mind and to a smaller degree Phil Simms).  Warren Moon comes to mind if you want to look at pure stats that were very good but was never really a winner.  I personally go by a combination of many things and a lot of watching NFL for 45+ years.

I have come to the conclusion that Kirk is not the answer for us or any team for a march to a SB.  

Liked:
#12 · Mar 16, 7:37 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"Hawkvike25" said:
@"minny65" said:
@"JustinTime18™" said: Wait. Drafting a QB #1 overall didn't solve all of the Browns issues?

GTFO.


So instead, they "might" try and get the 12th pick of the 2017 draft - Watson.  Supposedly we dabbled with some interest and a ton of teams with and without a QB are/should be interested in Watson.  He would be an upgrade for about 25+ teams.  

Some Irony if the Browns pursue Watson:

"The Texans traded up to select Watson with the Browns #12 pick in the 2017 draft.  The Browns got Texans 1st round pick for 2018, which ended up being #1 and selected Mayfield:
"The Texans traded up in the draft to select Clemson’s Deshaun Watson with pick No. 12.
Houston dealt with the Browns to select Watson as their next franchise quarterback, after dealing Brock Osweiler to Cleveland earlier this year.
The Browns acquired pick No. 25 (selected Jabrill Peppers) and Houston’s 2018 first-rounder in the deal (ended up being #1 Mayfield). 



Be careful about saying he's an upgrade for that many teams as his career record is only 28-25, and 1-2 in the playoffs. As we know, this board uses record as it's main determining factor for QB's


I would say 10 years and 59-59-2 is a pretty fair assessment. 

Liked:
#13 · Mar 16, 9:58 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"Norse" said:
@"Hawkvike25" said:
@"minny65" said:
@"JustinTime18™" said: Wait. Drafting a QB #1 overall didn't solve all of the Browns issues?

GTFO.


So instead, they "might" try and get the 12th pick of the 2017 draft - Watson.  Supposedly we dabbled with some interest and a ton of teams with and without a QB are/should be interested in Watson.  He would be an upgrade for about 25+ teams.  

Some Irony if the Browns pursue Watson:

"The Texans traded up to select Watson with the Browns #12 pick in the 2017 draft.  The Browns got Texans 1st round pick for 2018, which ended up being #1 and selected Mayfield:
"The Texans traded up in the draft to select Clemson’s Deshaun Watson with pick No. 12.
Houston dealt with the Browns to select Watson as their next franchise quarterback, after dealing Brock Osweiler to Cleveland earlier this year.
The Browns acquired pick No. 25 (selected Jabrill Peppers) and Houston’s 2018 first-rounder in the deal (ended up being #1 Mayfield). 



Be careful about saying he's an upgrade for that many teams as his career record is only 28-25, and 1-2 in the playoffs. As we know, this board uses record as it's main determining factor for QB's


I would say 10 years and 59-59-2 is a pretty fair assessment. 


Using record to evaluate any player in the NFL, regardless of position, never creates a fair assessment. Team Game.

Fran Tarkenton went 56-73-4 during the first 10 years of his career. Finished with a 124-109-6 record. What was the difference? Much better TEAMS. Team Game.

Liked:
#14 · Mar 16, 10:14 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"Hawkvike25" said:
@"Norse" said:
@"Hawkvike25" said:
@"minny65" said:
@"JustinTime18™" said: Wait. Drafting a QB #1 overall didn't solve all of the Browns issues?

GTFO.


So instead, they "might" try and get the 12th pick of the 2017 draft - Watson.  Supposedly we dabbled with some interest and a ton of teams with and without a QB are/should be interested in Watson.  He would be an upgrade for about 25+ teams.  

Some Irony if the Browns pursue Watson:

"The Texans traded up to select Watson with the Browns #12 pick in the 2017 draft.  The Browns got Texans 1st round pick for 2018, which ended up being #1 and selected Mayfield:
"The Texans traded up in the draft to select Clemson’s Deshaun Watson with pick No. 12.
Houston dealt with the Browns to select Watson as their next franchise quarterback, after dealing Brock Osweiler to Cleveland earlier this year.
The Browns acquired pick No. 25 (selected Jabrill Peppers) and Houston’s 2018 first-rounder in the deal (ended up being #1 Mayfield). 



Be careful about saying he's an upgrade for that many teams as his career record is only 28-25, and 1-2 in the playoffs. As we know, this board uses record as it's main determining factor for QB's


I would say 10 years and 59-59-2 is a pretty fair assessment. 


Using record to evaluate any player in the NFL, regardless of position, never creates a fair assessment. Team Game.

Fran Tarkenton went 56-73-4 during the first 10 years of his career. Finished with a 124-109-6 record. What was the difference? Much better TEAMS. Team Game.



I guess one can dream. :3 :3

Liked:
#15 · Mar 16, 10:32 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0

To be honest, I thought when he went #1 overall that it was a huge wtf moment, not overly surprised myself…

Liked:
#16 · Mar 16, 11:53 AM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
Interesting note from
@mortreport on ESPN just now while talking Baker/Browns ("they're breaking up regardless" of Watson) -- they "want an adult at" QB.

"Jimmy Garoppolo is one I would not ignore for Cleveland."

Liked:
#17 · Mar 16, 1:37 PM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"JustinTime18™" said:
Interesting note from
@mortreport on ESPN just now while talking Baker/Browns ("they're breaking up regardless" of Watson) -- they "want an adult at" QB.

"Jimmy Garoppolo is one I would not ignore for Cleveland."



not that Baker is a proven winner,  but can anybody remind me again how many firsts they spent on QBs in the last 20 years and how many playoffs games they went to in that time prior to Mayfield?   seems to me that they are kinda playing with fire over there.

Liked:
#18 · Mar 16, 1:42 PM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"JimmyinSD" said:
@"JustinTime18™" said:
Interesting note from
@mortreport on ESPN just now while talking Baker/Browns ("they're breaking up regardless" of Watson) -- they "want an adult at" QB.

"Jimmy Garoppolo is one I would not ignore for Cleveland."



not that Baker is a proven winner,  but can anybody remind me again how many firsts they spent on QBs in the last 20 years and how many playoffs games they went to in that time prior to Mayfield?   seems to me that they are kinda playing with fire over there.

 Manziel
WeedenQuinn

To name a vomit inducing few.

Liked:
#19 · Mar 16, 1:47 PM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"JustinTime18™" said:
@"JimmyinSD" said:
@"JustinTime18™" said:
Interesting note from
@mortreport on ESPN just now while talking Baker/Browns ("they're breaking up regardless" of Watson) -- they "want an adult at" QB.

"Jimmy Garoppolo is one I would not ignore for Cleveland."



not that Baker is a proven winner,  but can anybody remind me again how many firsts they spent on QBs in the last 20 years and how many playoffs games they went to in that time prior to Mayfield?   seems to me that they are kinda playing with fire over there.

 Manziel
WeedenQuinn

To name a vomit inducing few.



Want to know how you really F*ck up a franchise? 1st round picks from 2011-2016 they had 9...number of Pro Bowls or All Pros from those 9 picks? 0 for both.

Liked:
#20 · Mar 16, 2:00 PM
DE
Joined Apr 2026
206,512 posts
Rep: 0
@"JimmyinSD" said:
@"JustinTime18™" said:
Interesting note from
@mortreport on ESPN just now while talking Baker/Browns ("they're breaking up regardless" of Watson) -- they "want an adult at" QB.

"Jimmy Garoppolo is one I would not ignore for Cleveland."



not that Baker is a proven winner,  but can anybody remind me again how many firsts they spent on QBs in the last 20 years and how many playoffs games they went to in that time prior to Mayfield?   seems to me that they are kinda playing with fire over there.


 

Think the Browns was looking for a 3 way.
Cousins to Browns, Watson to the Vikings and Mayfield to the Texans.
But that didn’t happen.

Liked:
#21 · Mar 16, 2:31 PM
Log in to reply.

Edit Post (mod action — author will see a notice)

Warn Poster

Suspend User (3 days)

The user will be suspended for 3 days and will receive an email with the reason and information about how to appeal.

Forum The Longship Giving up on the #1 overall pick in a Draft?
Return to top ↑

Welcome to VikeFans!

Welcome back, Skol fans! This is our new home. Log in with your username or email and your existing password.


Be sure to check out the How To's and Questions forum for guides on getting around the new site, and use the Help Request forum if you run into anything that you need help with. Skol!