I am so conflicted on what direction I would like to see the team take.
Case, I really like his durability ( theres no ability like availability) his mobility is a huge plus, and his keeping his eyes down field. I dont like some of his decision making and he still has the issue of locking onto a target at times as well as holding the ball to long. his lack of arm strength could be problematic at times, but he has seemed to be able to work with it in target selection. I am not convinced he is a long term starter and I dont like the thought of locking our cap up on him for more than 1 year at this point. ( make him prove that this year wasnt a fluke)
Sam, the best arm talent of the bunch, but those knees. His lack of mobility and the continued injury issue would have me offering him a contract that is very very incentive laden with not much guaranteed.
Teddy, positives... youth, smarts, great attitude, decent (not great) arm. questions- showed good promise 2 years ago in preseason but after missing 2 seasons we have no idea what he will look like, his knee got the green light from the doctors, but how healthy is it long term? I would say that Teddy has the most upside, but also has the most questions of the 3 since he was not even close to a finished product and already was showing like a pro QB, but so much time off and medical concerns... a prove it deal at most and he will have to compete for the #1 with another starting caliber type QB.
I think Teddy and Case would make the most sense but I just dont see either wanting to stay here and compete. I think as smiley as both guys are, the situation may have been becoming mildly toxic and neither seem like the type to want to compete in that type of environment. perhaps picking one and then bringing in a fresh face to compete would be the best... but who to keep and who to try and bring in?