Going from arm talent to arm talent

[StickierBuns]

https://twitter.com/DraftAnalyst365/stat...0034457853


Football Scout 365
@DraftAnalyst365
The common misconception about J.J. McCarthy coming out of Michigan is that he was a checkdown merchant—that was never the case. In this small sample, @ChaseDaniel does a great job breaking down the arm talent McCarthy possesses.

"I clipped this because it’s a great example of why Michigan chose McCarthy over a Big Ten Championship-winning QB in his sophomore year.

He was too good to keep off the field, and while his predecessor was a good decision-maker, he didn’t have the arm talent McCarthy possesses. Jim Harbaugh knew McCarthy was the guy to take Michigan to the next level.

In this clip, it would have been easy for McCarthy to hit the checkdown against this Tampa 2, but instead, he chose the more difficult throw, which required timing, accuracy and his ability to layer it over the underneath defender." - FootballScout365

[Bullazin]

Liked watching Jurgens again too. He’s probs going to struggle with power in pass pro at times but hopefully his aiss fills out.

Kenny wongwu, what a bust. He was scared to get hit.

[JustInTime]

https://twitter.com/DraftAnalyst365/stat...0034457853


Football Scout 365
@DraftAnalyst365
The common misconception about J.J. McCarthy coming out of Michigan is that he was a checkdown merchant—that was never the case. In this small sample, @ChaseDaniel does a great job breaking down the arm talent McCarthy possesses.

"I clipped this because it’s a great example of why Michigan chose McCarthy over a Big Ten Championship-winning QB in his sophomore year.

He was too good to keep off the field, and while his predecessor was a good decision-maker, he didn’t have the arm talent McCarthy possesses. Jim Harbaugh knew McCarthy was the guy to take Michigan to the next level.

In this clip, it would have been easy for McCarthy to hit the checkdown against this Tampa 2, but instead, he chose the more difficult throw, which required timing, accuracy and his ability to layer it over the underneath defender." - FootballScout365

The only thing missing from his college tape is volume. He makes all the throws. Has all the skills. Has all the traits. But you never see the 34-43 for 495 yards and 4 touchdowns. He wasn’t asked to do that. I’m fine with that because if he had he would’ve been gone sooner.

[Montana Tom]

The only thing missing from his college tape is volume. He makes all the throws. Has all the skills. Has all the traits. But you never see the 34-43 for 495 yards and 4 touchdowns. He wasn’t asked to do that. I’m fine with that because if he had he would’ve been gone sooner.

Being more of a dual threat QB with a balanced ground game seemed to have worked out pretty well for the Eagles last year.

[MaroonBells]

This is one of the things I liked most about McCarthy as a draft pick. The unknown. 

Like Diggs at Maryland, his talent was hidden within a team not able to showcase it. JJ has a very strong arm and weapon-level speed and athleticism--all of which were hidden within a run-and-play-defense team. It's shocking how many just assumed he didn't have those physical skills because of the offense he played in. If he had played at LSU would he have been Joe Burrow? I think it's very possible. 

Anyway, answering those questions are how you get a talent like Diggs in the 5th round....and maybe why a QB like McCarthy goes after 4 other QBs are taken.

[purplefaithful]

We didnt even get to fully take the wrapper off last pre-season.

I'm looking forward to 2025 with him starting and that home schedule is amazing...

Just had to send the Wilfs our season tix $$ this week. I hope to hell they make it as fun as 24 was.

[StickierBuns]

The only thing missing from his college tape is volume. He makes all the throws. Has all the skills. Has all the traits. But you never see the 34-43 for 495 yards and 4 touchdowns. He wasn’t asked to do that. I’m fine with that because if he had he would’ve been gone sooner.

Word.

---

This is one of the things I liked most about McCarthy as a draft pick. The unknown. 

Like Diggs at Maryland, his talent was hidden within a team not able to showcase it. JJ has a very strong arm and weapon-level speed and athleticism--all of which were hidden within a run-and-play-defense team. It's shocking how many just assumed he didn't have those physical skills because of the offense he played in. If he had played at LSU would he have been Joe Burrow? I think it's very possible. 

Anyway, answering those questions are how you get a talent like Diggs in the 5th round....and maybe why a QB like McCarthy goes after 4 other QBs are taken.

Agreed, every time they've asked JJM to raise it up to the bar, he's done it. And he'll do it in the NFL. And as you and Justin have mentioned, he's got ALL the skills. That's the rare part. Put him in the KOC offense and I think you do have Joe Burrow with a little Josh Allen thrown in there. We'll see.