Shedeur Sanders to the Giants at #3?

[StickierBuns]

Really? I know they need a QB, but taking Sanders at #3 would be seriously overdrafting him IMO. I love everything about Sanders except for his size and his arm strength, which is below average. They say he's 6'1 1/2" tall but he sure doesn't look like it to me. But he's got really good pocket awareness and accuracy. I think some of the throws he's completed in college might be INTs in the pros. 

I read what I wrote here and it sounds like I don't like him as a player, but I do. I just don't think he's the #3 overall pick in the Draft by any stretch.

[JimmyinSD]

I think he's got bust written all over him. His daddy built a team around him and they accomplished nothing. Hes had the best of everything football wise his whole life and hes done what exactly? ImO hes more name than game and that will become more apparent when he makes Sunday football. I would say third round talent at the highest and taht IMo is still over drafting him.

[MAD GAINZ]

I think he's got bust written all over him.  His daddy built a team around him and they accomplished nothing.  Hes had the best of everything football wise his whole life and hes done what exactly?  ImO hes more name than game and that will become more apparent when he makes Sunday football.  I would say third round talent at the highest and taht IMo is still over drafting him.

That's kinda harsh IMO.  He put Jackson State on the map and Colorado was not a football school until they got there.  Built some excitement around their program and won 9 games last season (7-2 conference record).

I think Shedeur might be the safest QB pick in the draft.  But I do agree with Sticky, he has a nice arm but it's not elite.  However, he's super accurate.  He gets into trouble when he tries to keep a big play alive, he just doesn't have the arm to make off platform throws and test defenses.

I think too many are lumping Deion's antics in with Shedeur. The QB class this year is much weaker than last year and he'll be over drafted but I think he can be a solid starter.  Which is what you want if you're picking a QB, no busts.

[JimmyinSD]

That's kinda harsh IMO.  He put Jackson State on the map and Colorado was not a football school until they got there.  Built some excitement around their program and won 9 games last season (7-2 conference record).

I think Shedeur might be the safest QB pick in the draft.  But I do agree with Sticky, he has a nice arm but it's not elite.  However, he's super accurate.  He gets into trouble when he tries to keep a big play alive, he just doesn't have the arm to make off platform throws and test defenses.

I think too many are lumping Deion's antics in with Shedeur. The QB class this year is much weaker than last year and he'll be over drafted but I think he can be a solid starter.  Which is what you want if you're picking a QB, no busts.

Ive been wrong before,  but have also called plenty of busts, my gut says bust on this one.  Time will tell.

[Zanary]

I think he's got bust written all over him.  His daddy built a team around him and they accomplished nothing.  Hes had the best of everything football wise his whole life and hes done what exactly?  ImO hes more name than game and that will become more apparent when he makes Sunday football.  I would say third round talent at the highest and taht IMo is still over drafting him.

I completely agree with this. The kid has a huge dose of hype behind him with his dad involved, and I think ol' "Primetime" looked awfully overrated against both Moss and Carter, back in the day. I think that the NFL world, out from under daddy's protection, be a brutal wake-up call to a kid whose talents might be solid, but I never saw them as crushing in any footage.

His base attributes won't help him much, and I don't see him easily surviving a series of ego bruisings. He's like JFF 2.0 to me.