Yesterday, 10:06 AM
(Yesterday, 09:36 AM)supafreak84 Wrote: I was referencing for this upcoming season. I think it would be difficult for a rookie safety to make much of an impact outside of special teams and I think it's imperative we get an immediate return on investment, not only for the team but also a GM who doesn't have a contract extension and has gotten basically zero impact from 3 of the 4 first round picks he's made. Why draft a safety who will be firmly buried behind two high performing vets (Smith/Mattelus), a young guy who was just extended in Theo Jackson (who the head coach is excited about), and maybe even Jay Ward who has been in and learned a complex system for a couple years already. Why, when we could realistically draft a starting lineman or an impact weapon to help out the young quarterback? If we are talking for next season, yes you could draft and stash a rookie safety looking for them to start in 2026, but in my opinion you'd get a minimal return on investment for this season and I don't think we are in a position to do that.
I guess I don't see a G, DT, RB, CB as any different. IOW, I don't see those positions having an easier path to a starting job than a Safety. The CB, DT and RB would be rotational at best. I'm also not sure why so many assume that the guard we take there will immediately start ahead of Brandel. I was looking at the guards taken in the first round the last 3 years. Couple were busts and a couple were OK. None were very good out of the gate. But the assumption seems to be that a guard will be our path to an elite OL.
That's probably true for any position, but for the first time in many years, I think the Vikings are in a unique position to take the best player available (among our needs). I think we should just do that and not worry as much about the DEGREE of need at a particular position. JMO.