04-25-2020, 03:00 PM
Quote: @FSUVike said:
@kmillard said:
Totally agree with this but it takes two to tango. We'd all be on here bitching up a storm if Rick overpaid to move up to get 1 kid with so many holes left on the team. If the Browns hadn't taken Elliott this would have been my favorite Draft ever.@FSUVike said:
OH I get that. I never thought they would fill all their needs, but I feel the odds are better stacked at the top for better ROI in the draft. Would have loved to see them do what the saints did with us and trade up for Madebuike to add to the other picks and I would be ok with that. Hope they don't get too cute today and we get a backup long snapper and holder.@kmillard said:
I can't stand how often Rick bails in the mid Rounds to pick late.@purplefaithful said:
3T imo was our biggest need going into the draft. Wasn't sure how/when it would be addressed. So far it hasn't.
Seems like it wasn't for lack of trying. Or just plain drafting for need and not going BPA.
All that said, was this 3rd corner really that much better than the DL left? Or Gladney?
I'm not a draftnik and cant answer that definitively. They could have traded up but rick covets his 7th round garbage too much. I bet they end up with even more 7th rounders before the day is over. I wanted no picks after round 5 and they had the ammo to move up into the 2 and at least the 3rd a few times. Quality over quantity.
But if you think he was going to fill all of the holes on the team in one Draft you're not being realistic. Rick's best Draft ever yielded Waynes, Kendricks,
Hunter and Diggs. Guess what? Only Kendricks was a Day 1 Starter.
Going back to 2012 the most Day 1 Starters Spielman has procured is 2 (Kalil/Smith, Cook/Elflien). 2. Not 4. 2.
Minnesota lost 7 Starters and 2 heavy rotation players (I lump Sendejo & Kearse together). They've added 2 Starters, which is being kind to Sharpe, and 1 rotational player. On top of that they needed new (i.e., not on the Roster) talent at LG and 3T as well.
Any way you slice it Minnesota either needed at least 4 Day 1 Starters out of the Draft OR a combination of Rookies and stretches like Watts and Boyd to step up. AND they don't replace Elf at LG. AND they have no rotational DEs. AND they have zero Safety depth.
It was never, ever going to happen all in one Draft. No matter how great. Someone is likely to chime in with success stories like Harris, Weatherly, Odenigbo, etc. Not a single one of them was a consistent rotational contributor as a Rookie. While Rick is likely to find more contributors today and in UDFA, history says they won't help the team in 2020.
Minnesota isn't done. They have enough money for a Tier 2 FA (Everson may actually be the best one still available), or a couple of Tier 3 guys. They can still swing a trade. Roster cuts could produce an unexpected gem. This team is not in danger of failing to field a full Roster. It realistically never had a chance at being as good on paper as last year's Roster, no matter how well Rick did in the Draft.
I just read this after posting above........Would have been my favorite as well with Elliott who I wanted pre-draft big time.
