Forum › The Longship › KOC For A 1st?

KOC For A 1st?

JustInTime
Joined Feb 2025
6,254 posts
Rep: 4,969

Reckless speculation but…

“Hell is empty and all the devils are here”

Shakespeare 

Liked:
#1 · Nov 17, 1:00 PM
medaille
Joined Mar 2014
1,202 posts
Rep: 1,489

Magnus1018 wrote:

I know people are frustrated with QB play over the past 1.5 seasons, QB decisions, customizing the offense to the players we have, etc. Those are legitimate questions and concerns. But to want to throw away a coach who got to 50 wins a game faster than Bud Grant? Who has led the team to a 13 win season, and a 14 win season with 2 different QBs? For a first round pick roll of the dice? Yeah I am painfully aware of the playoff record.
Look I don’t want to lose Flores, but he did have his share of problems as a HC in Miami before the whole lawsuit issue. Maybe he has learned and will be better the second time around. Who would you want to bring in to run the offense with Flores as HC? QB? How would that impact JJ and his desire to stay here long term?
I want to see KOC and the team win at least one playoff game this year. I am in the camp of wanting to see how this season plays out before going head over heels to trade away our head coach for a draft pick at this point.

I feel like what you are saying is that the bad parts of the team (The offense and QB play) are not KOC's fault, but the good parts (the defense and ST) are credited to him.

Who would replace KOC as OC if we have Flores as HC? Does it really matter? Keep Kirk Cousins. He'll spearhead a competent offense. He's had competent offenses everywhere he's been except maybe the achilles year. Almost every OC can field a functional offense with the massive amount of talent we have on offense and Kirk Cousins as QB. Being good with this much talent on offense and a Flores defense is a low bar to get over.

Liked:
#42 · Nov 18, 12:28 PM CT
greediron
greediron
Mod
Joined May 2013
2,082 posts
Rep: 2,079

medaille wrote:

Kind of the same situation we have now. Great defenses ... sometimes competent offenses ... sometimes we're the embarrassment of the league offense-wise.
I get your point though. I'm normally of the belief that you should hire an offensive HC just because of the stability it provides with your QB. I just feel different about Flores. Flores's scheme is going to go down as one of those league changing schemes that is historical. I just don't think there's any real solid path to beating it for teams that have a young developing QB or any QB that's more athlete than intellectual. I think it's the biggest single field tilter outside of having an elite QB.

I agree about Flores. My question is, how long is it going to last. Teams will figure out how to beat it. Hopefully not this year, but they will adjust. Or the League will make changes to help the offense.

Liked:
#43 · Nov 18, 1:47 PM CT
medaille
Joined Mar 2014
1,202 posts
Rep: 1,489

greediron wrote:

I agree about Flores. My question is, how long is it going to last. Teams will figure out how to beat it. Hopefully not this year, but they will adjust. Or the League will make changes to help the offense.

I think maybe the elite offenses will find a way to beat it. But like half the league is starting QBs that aren't smart enough or have enough experience to sort through that amount of confusion. That will not change. There is nothing you can do if your QB is still developing. This isn't a situation where elite minds just need to develop better schemes or put the right players in the right spots on the field. This is asking your QB to process the field twice as fast as they're capable of without making mistakes.

Liked:
#44 · Nov 18, 2:20 PM CT
greediron
greediron
Mod
Joined May 2013
2,082 posts
Rep: 2,079

As he says, KOC is not the problem.

Liked:
#45 · Nov 18, 3:36 PM CT
medaille
Joined Mar 2014
1,202 posts
Rep: 1,489

greediron wrote:

As he says, KOC is not the problem.

A week or two ago, Kurt Warner, who was inarguably a better QB, said KOC was the problem.

Which one should I believe and why?

Liked:
#46 · Nov 18, 4:18 PM CT
Mike Olson
Mike Olson
Admin
Joined May 2013
666 posts
Rep: 604

SurfnRide wrote:

Yeah lets go can a guy who is 50-25 with a non stop ferris wheel of QB's.

Only Vikings fans would think this. GTFOOHWTBS

The non-stop QB carousel is part of his own doing. 1 playoff win under his tenure. 3 total under the wilfs dating back to 2005. The last 2 decades has been absolutely horrible football. KOC is a big part of that as well.

Is this thing STILL on?

Skol Vikes!

Liked:
#47 · Nov 18, 4:38 PM CT
medaille
Joined Mar 2014
1,202 posts
Rep: 1,489

I feel like some people will pretend that KOC just doesn’t have any influence over which QBs he’s had, but this past offseason, in which KOC and Flores has full control over the roster (with Brez making sure they didn’t go crazy), we chose to go with Kyler instead of Cousins.

KOC chose Kyler over Cousins. Cousins cried on TV about coming back here. KOC chose Kyler over Cousins.

We’re not talking about Cousins making tons of money.  Cousins is making like $10M for this year.

KOC is the self-proclaimed QB Killer.  He calls himself this because he wants to have a quick ax on getting rid of the guys that won’t work in his system.  Let that sink in.

edited Nov 18, 2026 4:48 PM CT
Liked:
#48 · Nov 18, 4:45 PM CT
greediron
greediron
Mod
Joined May 2013
2,082 posts
Rep: 2,079

medaille wrote:

I feel like some people will pretend that KOC just doesn’t have any influence over which QBs he’s had, but this past offseason, in which KOC and Flores has full control over the roster (with Brez making sure they didn’t go crazy), we chose to go with Kyler instead of Cousins.
KOC chose Kyler over Cousins. Cousins cried on TV about coming back here. KOC chose Kyler over Cousins.
We’re not talking about Cousins making tons of money.  Cousins is making like $10M for this year.
KOC is the self-proclaimed QB Killer.  He calls himself this because he wants to have a quick ax on getting rid of the guys that won’t work in his system.  Let that sink in.

I am not saying he hasn't made poor decisions in the QBs he has brought in. That is pretty obvious, bringing in Murray was a disaster. Even I could have (and did) predict that. But his offense, his play calling is not the issue. Murray and Wentz just wouldn't throw the ball. Maybe KOC is too demanding on not turning the ball over. Maybe KOC needs a QB with a big enough ego to say to hell with that, I am doing in my way. Not sure, but the plays are there, have been all season. Now we have a QB that can hit them.

Liked:
#49 · Nov 18, 4:55 PM CT
medaille
Joined Mar 2014
1,202 posts
Rep: 1,489

I think some players are just lost causes.  Others I believe are coachable and a good coach will get more out of those players than a bad coach.  I kind of think Kyler’s and Wentz’s ceilings aren’t very high for any coach, but also … objectively … every other coach got more out of Kyler than KOC did with worse supporting casts, Wentz didn’t have like the 3rd worst QB performance in history for a different coach (making that last stat up, not looking it up), JJM with the Giants?  IDK.

I don’t think I’m asking a lot out of KOC.  I’m not saying, make Kyler into a superstar.  I’m saying … perhaps just don’t have the worst offense in the league with a guy everyone says is an average starter before the season started.

KOC said his goal was to raise the floor of the QB.  The 3 guys he selected for his room and which he designed his offense around all failed under his tutelage, and we had to go get a guy who’s been pretty good everywhere he’s went to be pretty good here.  This offense is stacked.  It shouldn’t be hard to be at least average with this roster.

We can see receivers running routes open.  We can see the QBs not throwing them the ball.  Is it because QB after QB after QB are all just too lazy or dumb? Or is it because KOC did a bad job getting them to understand the offense?  I don’t think playcalling is the only thing a coach does.  If that was the case, they wouldn’t have to come into work all year, just hand those guys the magic book and call it a day.  Like why are people saying the QBs are lazy, but no one is saying that KOC is lazy?  If a kid can’t read, obviously it just means the kid is dumb, right?  There’s no way schools have any influence on how well a kid does at things right?  This is what I’m hearing in this conversation.

Liked:
#50 · Nov 18, 5:19 PM CT
greediron
greediron
Mod
Joined May 2013
2,082 posts
Rep: 2,079

medaille wrote:

I think some players are just lost causes.  Others I believe are coachable and a good coach will get more out of those players than a bad coach.  I kind of think Kyler’s and Wentz’s ceilings aren’t very high for any coach, but also … objectively … every other coach got more out of Kyler than KOC did with worse supporting casts, Wentz didn’t have like the 3rd worst QB performance in history for a different coach (making that last stat up, not looking it up), JJM with the Giants?  IDK.
I don’t think I’m asking a lot out of KOC.  I’m not saying, make Kyler into a superstar.  I’m saying … perhaps just don’t have the worst offense in the league with a guy everyone says is an average starter before the season started.
KOC said his goal was to raise the floor of the QB.  The 3 guys he selected for his room and which he designed his offense around all failed under his tutelage, and we had to go get a guy who’s been pretty good everywhere he’s went to be pretty good here.  This offense is stacked.  It shouldn’t be hard to be at least average with this roster.
We can see receivers running routes open.  We can see the QBs not throwing them the ball.  Is it because QB after QB after QB are all just too lazy or dumb? Or is it because KOC did a bad job getting them to understand the offense?  I don’t think playcalling is the only thing a coach does.  If that was the case, they wouldn’t have to come into work all year, just hand those guys the magic book and call it a day.  Like why are people saying the QBs are lazy, but no one is saying that KOC is lazy?  If a kid can’t read, obviously it just means the kid is dumb, right?  There’s no way schools have any influence on how well a kid does at things right?  This is what I’m hearing in this conversation.

Word is the practices were great. Wentz and Murray looked good until they shit the bed during the game. That is on the qb to execute. Obviously KOC coaches them up during the week, prepares them for the game plan. Nobody was heard saying he looked terrible in practice.

Wentz was a known quantity. He was a serviceable backup, good arm and size, but mentally would make stupid decisions. Played well week 1. Murray wasn't a fit and many of us knew it. KOC arrogantly thought he could mold him into a QB for his system. To his credit KOC tried to change the system to fit the QB. But Murray was the QB that was benched in AZ last year. Guess getting paid once was enough for him. Was he ever the same after getting paid?

Point is. Cousins came in on 3 days and lit it up, ran the offense efficiently and effectively. So it wasn't the offense, it was the execution.

Liked:
#51 · Nov 18, 5:49 PM CT
Vanguard83
Joined May 2013
611 posts
Rep: 707

^^^ Agree, Execution is key, but I would add that Cousins has the intelligence on pre-snap, and moxie / grit to audible, and that comes from experience in reading defenses. Being IN the game there's a lot of Field General that needs to happen - Sometimes a QB's feel for the game is more important than the guys on the sideline.

Liked:
#52 · Nov 18, 5:57 PM CT
kmillard
Joined Aug 2013
234 posts
Rep: 240

Mike Olson wrote:

The non-stop QB carousel is part of his own doing. 1 playoff win under his tenure. 3 total under the wilfs dating back to 2005. The last 2 decades has been absolutely horrible football. KOC is a big part of that as well.

That would be 0.

Liked:
#53 · Nov 19, 8:58 AM CT
Bullazin
Joined Jul 2013
631 posts
Rep: 482

Udinski’s next stop is an HC job.

Flores will likely be a DC in perpetuity

KOC is an excellent HC

Liked:
#54 · Nov 19, 9:29 AM CT
KM
Joined Sep 2017
178 posts
Rep: 253

Bullazin wrote:

Udinski’s next stop is an HC job.
Flores will likely be a DC in perpetuity
KOC is an excellent HC

Ultimately I think this is the case which is good for the Vikings.

Liked:
#55 · Nov 19, 9:49 AM CT
Vikesrock
Vikesrock
Champ
Joined Jan 2014
337 posts
Rep: 609

Bullazin wrote:

Udinski’s next stop is an HC job.
Flores will likely be a DC in perpetuity
KOC is an excellent HC

KOC is a good head coach, he is an average OC. And so far a poor developer of talent.

I would think trading him is a ridiculous proposition right now, but if he fails to win a playoff game this year, all bets are off.

Also, I would be searching for a real OC and give McCown his walking papers. Mick Lombardi comes to mind as an OC, but I am not sure how much he is involved in the 9ers offense. I am sure we could find someone...

Liked:
#56 · Nov 19, 9:56 AM CT
purplefaithful
Joined May 2013
10,265 posts
Rep: 7,330

McCown was getting quite a bit of interest from other teams last year and I wouldn't be surprised if he isnt working elsewhere in 27.

Not sure his star is shining quite so bright after the performance of Vikings QB's as of late? We could argue that till the cows come home I suppose.

They blew it not promoting Udinski to OC when they had the chance. I'll forever believe that really hurt JJM in particular.

Anyways, I wouldn’t be shedding many tears if the QB Coach & OC were both replaced.

Hurry-up Vikings, we ain't getting any younger! 

Liked:
#57 · Nov 19, 10:03 AM CT
Log in to reply.

Edit Post (mod action — author will see a notice)

Warn Poster

Suspend User (3 days)

The user will be suspended for 3 days and will receive an email with the reason and information about how to appeal.

Forum › The Longship › KOC For A 1st?
Return to top ↑

Welcome to VikeFans!

Welcome back, Skol fans! This is our new home. Log in with your username or email and your existing password.


Be sure to check out the How To's and Questions forum for guides on getting around the new site, and use the Help Request forum if you run into anything that you need help with. Skol!

You belong here, Vikings fan.

Join the VikeFans community to share your takes, react to posts, and talk Vikings with fans who get it.