Forum › The Longship › So now the question is.....

So now the question is.....

Vikesrock
Vikesrock
Champ
Joined Jan 2014
317 posts
Rep: 576

What do you do with Murray, Wentz and Brosmer? I had thought we would have seen Brosmer waived to the PS already, but it looks like they released OBJ instead. You can't carry 4 QB's, and I am not sure how Murray is going to take the permanent demotion. Trade deadline is over, so you can't anything back for him. Do you release him? Tell him to buck up on the bench? Are we going forward with Cousins, Wentz backup and Murray as the emergency QB?

If it was me, I would tell Murray to suck it up. Injuries happen in the NFL, and you are under contract. Make him the emergency QB and roll on...

One edit...maybe you stick Murray on IR with the "hamstring" injury and go with Cousins, Wentz, and Brosmer as emergency.

edited Nov 11, 2026 9:25 AM
Liked:
#1 · Nov 11, 9:22 AM
MaroonBells
Joined Jan 2014
5,593 posts
Rep: 6,157

Vikesrock wrote:

What do you do with Murray, Wentz and Brosmer? I had thought we would have seen Brosmer waived to the PS already, but it looks like they released OBJ instead. You can't carry 4 QB's, and I am not sure how Murray is going to take the permanent demotion. Trade deadline is over, so you can't anything back for him. Do you release him? Tell him to buck up on the bench? Are we going forward with Cousins, Wentz backup and Murray as the emergency QB?If it was me, I would tell Murray to suck it up. Injuries happen in the NFL, and you are under contract. Make him the emergency QB and roll on...

You really want to put Wentz in if Kirk goes down? No, obviously when Kyler's healthy he should be the backup. But I don't know how this impacts locker room, personalities, etc.

"Evan Can't Fish" —Bathroom wall, The Filling Station, Bozeman, MT

Liked:
#2 · Nov 11, 9:25 AM CT
StickierBuns
Joined May 2013
11,037 posts
Rep: 3,450

To The Moon Gme GIF by Partiful

Liked:
#3 · Nov 11, 9:25 AM CT
avike
Joined Apr 2026
71 posts
Rep: 100

I wonder if Brosmer goes to the practice squad when all 4 QBs are healthy. Next week, Brosmer might need to be the back-up if Wentz is not good to go, but otherwise he will be the emergency QB (must be on the 53 for this to happen) while Murry is out.

Liked:
#4 · Nov 11, 9:28 AM CT
Vikesrock
Vikesrock
Champ
Joined Jan 2014
317 posts
Rep: 576

MaroonBells wrote:

You really want to put Wentz in if Kirk goes down? No, obviously when Kyler's healthy he should be the backup. But I don't know how this impacts locker room, personalities, etc.

No, God no, but Murray was still listed as Out and injured. Honestly, neither option is good if Cousins goes down. I also wonder what Murray's head will be like.

The only thought for Wentz as the backup would be that it would cause less of a seismic game plan change then Murray would require.

Liked:
#5 · Nov 11, 9:36 AM CT
MaroonBells
Joined Jan 2014
5,593 posts
Rep: 6,157

Vikesrock wrote:

No, God no, but Murray was still listed as Out and injured. Honestly, neither option is good if Cousins goes down. I also wonder what Murray's head will be like.
The only thought for Wentz as the backup would be that it would cause less of a seismic game plan change then Murray would require.

I think your second point might have some validity. But when he's healthy, I'd much rather have Kyler in there than Wentz. He's obviously not been the QB many of us expected him to be, but I think people are exaggerating how bad he was. In his last 4 games his passer rating never went under 90. Against Buffalo, Wentz's passer rating was 8! LOL. Murray threw 4 TDs and 1 INT. And the pick was not actually a pick. At one point in this stretch, he'd hit 40 of 48 passes. He never once fumbled. He's capable of breaking a defense's back with his legs and throwing passes like this. Don't make me show you that Wentz clip.

edited Nov 11, 2026 10:13 AM CT

"Evan Can't Fish" —Bathroom wall, The Filling Station, Bozeman, MT

Liked:
#6 · Nov 11, 10:12 AM CT
greediron
greediron
Mod
Joined May 2013
2,040 posts
Rep: 2,008

Vikesrock wrote:

What do you do with Murray, Wentz and Brosmer? I had thought we would have seen Brosmer waived to the PS already, but it looks like they released OBJ instead. You can't carry 4 QB's, and I am not sure how Murray is going to take the permanent demotion. Trade deadline is over, so you can't anything back for him. Do you release him? Tell him to buck up on the bench? Are we going forward with Cousins, Wentz backup and Murray as the emergency QB?If it was me, I would tell Murray to suck it up. Injuries happen in the NFL, and you are under contract. Make him the emergency QB and roll on...One edit...maybe you stick Murray on IR with the "hamstring" injury and go with Cousins, Wentz, and Brosmer as emergency.

To me Murray will be the backup once he is healthy. Wentz probably gets cut at that point IMO.

Guess it also depends on what Murray's attitude is regarding all this. He could pout and never recover from the hammy.

edited Nov 11, 2026 10:20 AM CT
Liked:
#7 · Nov 11, 10:19 AM CT
StickierBuns
Joined May 2013
11,037 posts
Rep: 3,450

greediron wrote:

To me Murray will be the backup once he is healthy. Wentz probably gets cut at that point IMO.

Yep. Give me K1 as the primary backup. Completely another style for opposing Ds to deal with in the event of a Cousins injury.

Liked:
#8 · Nov 11, 10:20 AM CT
medaille
Joined Mar 2014
1,184 posts
Rep: 1,469

No reason to overthink it.  You just move Brosmer to practice squad once Murray is healthy enough to back up the QB spot.

We had a bad game with Wentz.  A really bad game.  We’ve also had games from Wentz that was acceptable.  Not great, but acceptable.  We’ve only had bad games with Brosmer. 

Liked:
#9 · Nov 11, 10:24 AM CT
Montana Tom
Joined May 2013
1,221 posts
Rep: 1,742

medaille wrote:
We had a bad game with Wentz.  A really bad game.  We’ve also had games from Wentz that was acceptable.  Not great, but acceptable.  We’ve only had bad games with Brosmer.

I beg to differ...Wentz had a bad game yes, but the things you look for, decisiveness, accurate throwing, and other technical attributes that we all saw with our own eyes...were not there. I watched Case Keenam win in Chicago as a backup when Caleb Johnson was down...totally different look and feel...calm. Accurate. Wentz was the antithesis of Keenam in his backup role.

Please God, just one Lombardi before I die.

Liked:
#10 · Nov 11, 10:28 AM CT
medaille
Joined Mar 2014
1,184 posts
Rep: 1,469

Montana Tom wrote:

I beg to differ...Wentz had a bad game yes, but the things you look for, decisiveness, accurate throwing, and other technical attributes that we all saw with our own eyes...were not there. I watched Case Keenam win in Chicago as a backup when Caleb Johnson was down...totally different look and feel...calm. Accurate. Wentz was the antithesis of Keenam in his backup role.

What’s the point you’re differing on.  Are suggesting that we cut Wentz and leave Brosmer as QB3.

Liked:
#11 · Nov 11, 10:34 AM CT
MA
Joined Apr 2024
938 posts
Rep: 1,977

MaroonBells wrote:

I think your second point might have some validity. But when he's healthy, I'd much rather have Kyler in there than Wentz. He's obviously not been the QB many of us expected him to be, but I think people are exaggerating how bad he was. In his last 4 games his passer rating never went under 90. Against Buffalo, Wentz's passer rating was 8! LOL. Murray threw 4 TDs and 1 INT. And the pick was not actually a pick. At one point in this stretch, he'd hit 40 of 48 passes. He never once fumbled. He's capable of breaking a defense's back with his legs and throwing passes like this. Don't make me show you that Wentz clip.
https://twitter.com/SeanBormanNFL/status/2116994881134465369

If only passer rating won games... Murray hasn't been good. Lots of empty completions, very few explosive plays, and some really bad misses. We've scored 11 TDs as an offense through 8 games.

5 of those 11 came with Wentz against Green Bay in Week 1. In Kyler's 5 games where he's started and played the whole game, we've scored 6 offensive TDs and broken 20+ points twice...

You can continue to prop him up, but he's been an absolute disaster in this offense.

Liked:
#12 · Nov 11, 10:38 AM CT
Kentis
Joined Oct 2013
1,079 posts
Rep: 1,273

MAD GAINZ wrote:

If only passer rating won games... Murray hasn't been good. Lots of empty completions, very few explosive plays, and some really bad misses. We've scored 11 TDs as an offense through 8 games.
5 of those 11 came with Wentz against Green Bay in Week 1. In Kyler's 5 games where he's started and played the whole game, we've scored 6 offensive TDs and broken 20+ points twice...
You can continue to prop him up, but he's been an absolute disaster in this offense.

And somehow Wentz was worse…

Liked:
#13 · Nov 11, 10:44 AM CT
greediron
greediron
Mod
Joined May 2013
2,040 posts
Rep: 2,008

Montana Tom wrote:

I beg to differ...Wentz had a bad game yes, but the things you look for, decisiveness, accurate throwing, and other technical attributes that we all saw with our own eyes...were not there. I watched Case Keenam win in Chicago as a backup when Caleb Johnson was down...totally different look and feel...calm. Accurate. Wentz was the antithesis of Keenam in his backup role.

Like when he came in against GB? Wentz is just so inconsistent. And his bad is very bad. Keenum got benched the next game IIRC.

Liked:
#14 · Nov 11, 10:45 AM CT
SurfnRide
Joined Oct 2024
304 posts
Rep: 372

Wentz should have been released when the clock struck 0:00 on MOnday

Cousins, Murray, Brosmer

Liked:
#15 · Nov 11, 10:47 AM CT
pattersaur
Joined Jul 2017
1,192 posts
Rep: 1,151

1c173d7e-4873-4cb8-b490-a3487ebf3344.gif

Liked:
#16 · Nov 11, 10:48 AM CT
StickierBuns
Joined May 2013
11,037 posts
Rep: 3,450

SurfnRide wrote:

100%. I dont know if your eyes were deceiving you on Monday but Wentz cant hit a wide open WR 5 yards away. He should have been cut the second the clock hit 0:00

MAD GAINZ wrote:


You can continue to prop him up, but he's been an absolute disaster in this offense.

This ^

I mean, at this point....don't we all understand that the K1 experiment was an abysmal failure? Its ok if some fans were more all in than others pre-live football, truly....I get some of the reasons for optimism. But it didn't happen and never manifested. And there was plenty to be cautious about in his career for fans to be guarded and wanting to see it first. And the dude is rarely healthy.

As a backup? Sure. Better than Wentz and Brosmer. After this season, get a giant broom and sweep all these duds out the door.

edited Nov 11, 2026 10:54 AM CT
Liked:
#17 · Nov 11, 10:50 AM CT
SurfnRide
Joined Oct 2024
304 posts
Rep: 372

medaille wrote:

What’s the point you’re differing on.  Are suggesting that we cut Wentz and leave Brosmer as QB3.

100%. I dont know if your eyes were deceiving you on Monday but Wentz cant hit a wide open WR 5 yards away. He should have been cut the second the clock hit 0:00

Liked:
#18 · Nov 11, 10:50 AM CT
purplefaithful
Joined May 2013
10,205 posts
Rep: 7,221

This whole Wentz on MNF leaves me shaking my head...

By all accounts he had a fantastic week of practice (against our all-world D) and everyone was on a high note going into the game.

And then he played the game and completely shat the bed.

Humans, u just cant trust em.

Hurry-up Vikings, we ain't getting any younger! 

Liked:
#19 · Nov 11, 12:02 PM CT
MaroonBells
Joined Jan 2014
5,593 posts
Rep: 6,157

MAD GAINZ wrote:

If only passer rating won games... Murray hasn't been good. Lots of empty completions, very few explosive plays, and some really bad misses. We've scored 11 TDs as an offense through 8 games.
5 of those 11 came with Wentz against Green Bay in Week 1. In Kyler's 5 games where he's started and played the whole game, we've scored 6 offensive TDs and broken 20+ points twice...
You can continue to prop him up, but he's been an absolute disaster in this offense.

As if passer rating is the only thing I mentioned. No, passer rating does not win football games, but Kyler was still 4-1. Yes, I’m aware that is mostly due to the defense. No doubt, he was bad. He missed open receivers and never got in sync with the offense. But it was far from a disaster. He protected the ball well, won games and completed 65% of his passes. A disaster is what we saw on Monday night. In his only two starts, Wentz’s completion percentage was 42%. You really want to go back to that if Kirk goes down? 

"Evan Can't Fish" —Bathroom wall, The Filling Station, Bozeman, MT

Liked:
#20 · Nov 11, 12:18 PM CT
Zanary
Joined May 2013
1,300 posts
Rep: 817

StickierBuns wrote:

Yep. Give me K1 as the primary backup. Completely another style for opposing Ds to deal with in the event of a Cousins injury.

Best of bad options. I don't know why Wentz managed to look worse than ever on Monday night, but I hope to never see him under center for the team again.

I've never been a believer in K1, but he's a better choice at this point...barely. I actually wonder if Brosmer should be QB2.

OK, the Cousins trade is a step towards lower assclown status, Teasley/KOC....

Liked:
#21 · Nov 11, 12:48 PM CT
Log in to reply.

Edit Post (mod action — author will see a notice)

Warn Poster

Suspend User (3 days)

The user will be suspended for 3 days and will receive an email with the reason and information about how to appeal.

Forum › The Longship › So now the question is.....
Return to top ↑

Welcome to VikeFans!

Welcome back, Skol fans! This is our new home. Log in with your username or email and your existing password.


Be sure to check out the How To's and Questions forum for guides on getting around the new site, and use the Help Request forum if you run into anything that you need help with. Skol!

You belong here, Vikings fan.

Join the VikeFans community to share your takes, react to posts, and talk Vikings with fans who get it.