2025 QB class looks weak
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
IMO, Shadeur Sanders is the obvious #1 with Cam Ward close. I think many NFL scouts might have it the other way around, but only from a physical attribute perspective, Ward's accuracy is going to be an issue in the NFL. The rest? Ewww. Why Texas isn't starting Arch Manning full time is a joke. Carson Beck? Wouldn't draft him at all. Jalen Milroe should be a running back. Think Michigan misses JJ McCarthy? I think this class is full of projects beyond Sanders and Ward and that wasn't the belief 3 months ago. NFL GMs have to be majorly gripping if their plan was to take a QB outside of the top 2. Its been brutal watching some of these 'top prospects' perform. Very happy Minnesota snagged their guy.
Watching Coach Prime and Shadeur's agent entourage maneuver to get away from BAD organizations in next year's Draft will be interesting. You think he'll allow Cleveland to draft his son? No f-ing way. And although I dislike the clown show going on in Colorado right now, I don't blame them.
Watching Coach Prime and Shadeur's agent entourage maneuver to get away from BAD organizations in next year's Draft will be interesting. You think he'll allow Cleveland to draft his son? No f-ing way. And although I dislike the clown show going on in Colorado right now, I don't blame them.
Liked:
![]()
#1
·
Oct 27, 3:49 AM
Oct 27, 2024 3:49 AM
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
MAD GAINZ wrote:
Agreed, this QB class is a bit underwhelming compared to last year's class.
I think the top two seem to have separated themselves, but I like Jalen Milroe as well. Not as a first round pick, but he reminds me of Oklahoma Jalen Hurts. I was high on Hurts coming out in that draft. I thought he was overlooked since most still thought he was just a running playmaking QB, but he developed more as a college passer after leaving Alabama. If a team is patient with Milroe, I think he can be a good NFL QB.
Not a bad comp for Milroe, Hurts. I will say Milroe is even more athletically gifted and has a slightly better arm.
I've really liked Sanders as far back as the beginning of last season. He has modern NFL QB written all over him: athletic, tough and accurate.
edited Oct 27, 2024 9:36 AM
Liked:
![]()
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
Montana Tom wrote:
Totally agree with this. Glad we got JJM in the fold now. I believe that Sanders will bring his father's attitude, and while he's good, he is not two professional sports good.
Hey Tom......he's pretty good. Look past the stuff that is the clown show at the University of Colorado and see the player. I'm with you on the rest, but he's going to be very good in the NFL.
Liked:
![]()
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
medaille wrote:
Sometimes the draft doesn’t have quality QBs when you have a desperate need to get one. You need to draft one when they are available, not when you have a need to get one.
In theory, of course. In reality? Teams needs QBs every year.....because the Draft is an inexact science. Bad choices are made every year. Teams draft when 'available' and still that QB can turn out to be a bust. Then you waste 2-3 years and now its an extreme 'need'. And the beat goes on.
Liked:
![]()
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
Canthony wrote:
Sanders #1 is just so out there for me. I dont see it. I think Ewers will be the first pick when it is all said and done.
Ewers might not even be a 2nd round pick when the college season is done. His stock is nosediving. Smallish guy with average arm strength who looked overwhelmed and skittish against Georgia, and was benched. Only reason Manning hasn't been named the starter is Sark doesn't want to do what he needs to do with Ewers: sit him. He's a good kid.
edited Oct 29, 2024 9:25 AM
Liked:
![]()
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
Kentis wrote:
Sam Darnold approves this OP… :P
Completely. If Darnold can continue to at least play decently the rest of the year, he'll be in a good spot via free agency this offseason.
Liked:
![]()
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
And oh yeah, big surprise: the media overhyped CJ Stroud. I think he'll be fine, but he's not the next great NFL Patrick Mahomes-level franchise QB.
Liked:
![]()
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
Other than Sanders, I don't think I'd want anyone from this upcoming class if I were NFL teams....including Cam Ward. Yeeesh. Beck looks like a completely different player than last season in the worst way possible. I think the next best thing coming in a few years will be the "March for Arch" Manning. Allar, other than good mobility, made some bad throws against Ohio State and a horrible pick in the end zone. There's no way I'd take Milroe in round 1......but someone might.
Bad, bad year to need a QB upcoming.
edited Nov 3, 2024 2:55 AM
Liked:
![]()
Log in to reply.
Edit Post (mod action — author will see a notice)
Warn Poster
Suspend User (3 days)
The user will be suspended for 3 days and will receive an email with the reason and information about how to appeal.