Forum The Longship The case for Kyler Murray

The case for Kyler Murray

StickierBuns
Joined May 2013
9,486 posts
Rep: 1,408

Let’s start a thread…..why our new QB1 is going to rock;

Liked:
#1 · Aug 13, 4:26 PM
Canthony
Canthony
July 2026 Trivia Champion
Joined Oct 2013
1,155 posts
Rep: 693

Starz Pay Me GIF by Power Book II: Ghost

Liked:
#2 · Aug 13, 4:50 PM CT
StickierBuns
Joined May 2013
9,486 posts
Rep: 1,408
Liked:
#3 · Aug 13, 5:18 PM CT
Vanguard83
Joined May 2013
477 posts
Rep: 458

Only ability I'm concerned about is his "availability"

If he's healthy, we could really do some damage.

Liked:
#4 · Aug 13, 5:34 PM CT
StickierBuns
Joined May 2013
9,486 posts
Rep: 1,408
Liked:
#5 · Aug 13, 5:42 PM CT
JustInTime
Joined Feb 2025
4,404 posts
Rep: 3,156

4bb66795-1d33-4055-8eef-8d5addad3f78.jpeg

“Hell is empty and all the devils are here”

Shakespeare 

Liked:
#6 · Aug 13, 5:43 PM CT
StickierBuns
Joined May 2013
9,486 posts
Rep: 1,408
Liked:
#7 · Aug 13, 5:56 PM CT
SA
Joined May 2013
154 posts
Rep: 109

Liked:
#8 · Aug 13, 8:24 PM CT
CFIAvike
Joined Aug 2017
124 posts
Rep: 137

Kyler Murray COULD be successful on this team if he plays antithetical to how he’s ever played.

Darnold was successful because he shut up and did EXACTLY what KOC wanted on literally every play. There were no audibles and there were extremely few off schedule plays. Darnold didn’t have to think… he just had to do what he was told.

Kyler literally exists off schedule. He scrambles just to scramble. He lobs grenades and throws check downs. He is the polar opposite of Sam Darnold.

However…he does possess tremendous physical ability. If he can shut up, play “boring”, stay healthy and do exactly what KOC wants…the Vikings can win a ton of games.

Nurture vs Nature ….which one wins.

Liked:
#9 · Aug 13, 10:14 PM CT
StickierBuns
Joined May 2013
9,486 posts
Rep: 1,408

CFIAvike wrote:

Kyler Murray COULD be successful on this team if he plays antithetical to how he’s ever played.
Darnold was successful because he shut up and did EXACTLY what KOC wanted on literally every play. There were no audibles and there were extremely few off schedule plays. Darnold didn’t have to think… he just had to do what he was told.
Kyler literally exists off schedule. He scrambles just to scramble. He lobs grenades and throws check downs. He is the polar opposite of Sam Darnold.
However…he does possess tremendous physical ability. If he can shut up, play “boring”, stay healthy and do exactly what KOC wants…the Vikings can win a ton of games.
Nurture vs Nature ….which one wins.

No doubt there are questions about Murray and I have some myself. Mentioned them previously in other threads. This thread is about how he COULD be successful and why he might. Its like Adam Thielen said when describing Minnesota's offense: 'you have to let O'Connell be the star'. Along that line, what other former associates and coaches who were willing to talk about Murray said, was he needs someone to tell him directly what to do and when he's messing up make him accountable. And I think his talented surround will do that as well. We brought you here to do this and this, so start doing it. Its an interesting insight into K1's demeanor if accurate. A good indicator is he's picking up the offense quickly, which at least right now shows dedication, aptitude and committment.

I think the difference is if Murray is driven enough competitively to want to jam it up the rear ends of his detractors with this new opportunity, it has a real chance to be special. Its not nature vs nurture, its what could happen when the two meet and prosper together in a new environment. I think what might upset the apple cart of a successful campaign is his health. And also the reason IF successful why Minnesota might be reticent to commit to him longer than this season.

edited Aug 14, 2026 5:22 AM CT
Liked:
#10 · Aug 14, 4:59 AM CT
CFIAvike
Joined Aug 2017
124 posts
Rep: 137

StickierBuns wrote:

No doubt there are questions about Murray and I have some myself. Mentioned them previously in other threads. This thread is about how he COULD be successful and why he might. Its like Adam Thielen said when describing Minnesota's offense: 'you have to let O'Connell be the star'. Along that line, what other former associates and coaches who were willing to talk about Murray said, was he needs someone to tell him directly what to do and when he's messing up make him accountable. And I think his talented surround will do that as well. We brought you here to do this and this, so start doing it. Its an interesting insight into K1's demeanor if accurate. A good indicator is he's picking up the offense quickly, which at least right now shows dedication, aptitude and committment.
I think the difference is if Murray is driven enough competitively to want to jam it up the rear ends of his detractors with this new opportunity, it has a real chance to be special. It’s not nature vs nurture, it’s what could happen when the two meet and prosper together in a new environment. I think what might upset the apple cart of a successful campaign is his health. And also the reason IF successful why Minnesota might be reticent to commit to him longer than this season.

I appreciate your positive outlook.

I just feel all evidence to Kyler’s character and demeanor suggest that he thinks a lot of himself for a #1 overall pick that’s produced very little in the way of success. I think it’s in his nature to constantly play outside of the game plan and improvise.

Like I said…he has all the physical tools you want. He and the team will be successful if he just fights the urge to do everything he wants to and falls in line. But will his ego allow himself to be coached and to be a simply a cog in the machine?

That was Darnold’s super power…just shut up, be unassuming and do exactly as you’re told.

Liked:
#11 · Aug 14, 7:22 AM CT
StickierBuns
Joined May 2013
9,486 posts
Rep: 1,408

CFIAvike wrote:

I appreciate your positive outlook.

I just feel all evidence to Kyler’s character and demeanor suggest that he thinks a lot of himself for a #1 overall pick that’s produced very little in the way of success. I think it’s in his nature to constantly play outside of the game plan and improvise.

Like I said…he has all the physical tools you want. He and the team will be successful if he just fights the urge to do everything he wants to and falls in line. But will his ego allow himself to be coached and to be a simply a cog in the machine?

That was Darnold’s super power…just shut up, be unassuming and do exactly as you’re told.

You may be right. Maybe his default mode is backyard football. We'll find out soon. I will say that no one is going to convince me he's some kind of leader, because he's not. But its not prerequisite for the job. Remember: there's a lot of 'coulds' and 'possibly' in my positive outlook.

edited Aug 14, 2026 7:28 AM CT
Liked:
#12 · Aug 14, 7:24 AM CT
pattersaur
Joined Jul 2017
883 posts
Rep: 814

This thread from Stickers feels like when the losing coach marches over and shakes the winning coach’s hand a little too vigorously 😉

Liked:
#13 · Aug 14, 7:39 AM CT
StickierBuns
Joined May 2013
9,486 posts
Rep: 1,408

pattersaur wrote:

This thread from Stickers feels like when the losing coach marches over and shakes the winning coach’s hand a little too vigorously 😉

Damned if you do or damned if you don't. I'm a Viking's fan. Ultimately, the name on the back of the jersey doesn't mean anything without wins. I guess the alternative is too just piss and moan all year about JJ not being QB1 and stink the board up? That's not me. I don't view this as losing or winning, its always been my opinion, although strongly worded sometimes, about JJ. 🙄

Liked:
#14 · Aug 14, 7:43 AM CT
JR44
Joined Aug 2017
786 posts
Rep: 979

CFIAvike wrote:

Kyler Murray COULD be successful on this team if he plays antithetical to how he’s ever played.
Darnold was successful because he shut up and did EXACTLY what KOC wanted on literally every play. There were no audibles and there were extremely few off schedule plays. Darnold didn’t have to think… he just had to do what he was told.
Kyler literally exists off schedule. He scrambles just to scramble. He lobs grenades and throws check downs. He is the polar opposite of Sam Darnold.
However…he does possess tremendous physical ability. If he can shut up, play “boring”, stay healthy and do exactly what KOC wants…the Vikings can win a ton of games.
Nurture vs Nature ….which one wins.

One of the things that made Darnold successful here was his ability to go off script, call audibles and make in play adjustments.

Every play does not go as plan, defenses consistently break up the intended play and you do have to improvise, it is part of the game and the best QBs in the league are the best for having that ability. So I am guessing you would not want Allen or Mahomes as your QB as well.

Liked:
#15 · Aug 14, 7:51 AM CT
Cricket
Cricket
Mod June 2026 Trivia Champion
Joined May 2013
1,777 posts
Rep: 1,582

https://www.si.com/nfl/vikings/onsi/four-reasons-to-be-excited-for-kyler-murray-in-minnesota-even-if-you-still-believe-in-j-j-mccarthy-01kzxsz18tzx

Four Reasons to Be Excited for Kyler Murray in Minnesota, Even If You Still Believe in J.J. McCarthy

As the heated QB debate settles, there's reason for hope in the Twin Cities.

EAGAN, MN — The summer of quarterback competition came to an end earlier this week, as head coach Kevin O’Connell officially announced Kyler Murray as the team's starter for the 2026 season. Naturally, every single Vikings fan reacted with equal enthusiasm and positivity to the news on social media. Jokes aside, the disconnect and disagreements make sense. 

This is a fanbase desperate for a long-term answer at the most important position in sports, and the success of a homegrown young QB was an easy plotline to root for. For the time being, that story looks to be on hold for J.J. McCarthy and the fans hoping to see him earn the starting role this season. Instead, the team will roll with former Heisman-winning first-overall pick in Murray. 

Murray’s initial signing with Minnesota was met with equal levels of intrigue and hesitation. Was he a fit for O’Connell’s offense? Were the stigmas attached to him in Arizona accurate? Why would the Cardinals seemingly pay him to leave? 

I’m glad to share that through the first two weeks of camp, none of these concerns seem to have much merit. In fact, things may be heading in a decidedly positive direction. Here are four reasons I believe Vikings fans should be optimistic with Murray at the helm.

1. Kevin O’Connell is playing to his strengths

Perhaps the most reasonable concern about the Murray-Minnesota marriage was the potential mismatch in scheme fits. Murray had taken the majority of his career snaps from the shotgun, while O’Connell tended to have his QBs operate from under center.

So far through camp, though, we are seeing a distinct blend between the two. O’Connell has integrated more shotgun formations and even showcased pistol formations as well in the early stages of camp. Murray’s mobility, combined with a new outside run scheme for his running backs, opens the door to numerous possibilities and variations in formation. 

Even when Murray has lined up under center, many of the concerns tossed around in the spring seem overblown so far. He’s very rarely used his legs through camp and has mostly proven capable of stepping up in the pocket and delivering accurate passes, despite pressure in his face.

The most optimistic outlook that should be taken from this is that Murray and O’Connell are approaching the perfect balance between sticking to a playbook with historic success and embracing his quarterback’s truly unique skillset. 

2. The connection with Justin Jefferson is forming in front of us

Justin Jefferson and the Vikings cannot afford a repeat of his 2025 output. While Jefferson has been the very definition of a team player and leader throughout his career in Minnesota, he’s not getting any younger. Jefferson enters year seven — yes, that's right, seven — with high expectations of a return to form. 

A career-low in yardage and a shocking two touchdowns in 2025 from him had some fans thinking the star wideout may be approaching the end of his patience, but he never wavered. Jefferson embraced the process of adding competition to the QB room and spent time working with both Murray and McCarthy in the offseason. Looks like that is paying off.

Jefferson and Murray are already forming a connection we’ve simply never seen him have with McCarthy. Murray is willing to throw less-than-perfect passes downfield with full trust in his WR1, a factor clearly missing from last year’s disastrous pass attack. Jefferson surpassed 1,500 yards in both seasons when the Vikings made the playoffs under O'Connell, a sure sign that his production is key to allowing the passing game to thrive. 

3. We’ve barely even seen Murray's mobility in action, yet

Murray is much more than a scrambler, but man, is he good at it. His 3,193 career rushing yards and 32 rushing touchdowns are a far cry from the prototypical QB build many Vikings fans have grown accustomed to. 

Murray hasn’t utilized his mobility much in camp, but when he has, it’s been impressive. Even in Wednesday’s practice, Murray used his legs on play action on 3rd and 1 to turn upfield and pick up the first down.

In total, the run may have netted a few yards, but the speed he showcased was cause for excitement. Last week, he showcased some longer scrambles, including a run up the middle for a touchdown at the team’s night practice.  Murray’s ability to gain yardage on the ground will be a huge addition to the Vikings’ offense, whether it's via a short first-down conversion or a breakaway touchdown.

4. He's one of us

Murray joins Carson Wentz in the quarterback room as two guys with Vikings-related trauma before they even joined the team. Both have been open about the fact that they grew up rooting for the purple and gold, but Murray’s story from his introductory presser hits home especially hard for a generation of Vikings fans.

Many of us can relate to Kyler’s formative experience in the 2009 NFC Championship game. A team with high expectations and elite talent, seemingly destined to win it all, loses in the most heartbreaking fashion possible. While this certainly does not guarantee anything about his performance on the field, he knows how much this team’s success truly means to the fanbase.

For a team with such a long history of pain and letdowns, that matters. Hopefully, Murray can bottle that childhood pain to bring joy to a new generation of Vikings faithful.


LIVE WELL ~ LOVE MUCH ~ LAUGH OFTEN

Liked:
#16 · Aug 14, 8:07 AM CT
JustInTime
Joined Feb 2025
4,404 posts
Rep: 3,156

Only player ever to be drafted in the top ten in two sports.

One of two QBs, the other being Josh Allen, to average 230 yards passing and 40 yards rushing per game (minimum of 50 starts)

Hand timed 4.38 at Oklahoma

Excellent arm

Fits in subcompact cars

edited Aug 14, 2026 9:04 AM CT

“Hell is empty and all the devils are here”

Shakespeare 

Liked:
#17 · Aug 14, 8:44 AM CT
SurfnRide
Joined Oct 2024
166 posts
Rep: 180

Vanguard83 wrote:

Only ability I'm concerned about is his "availability"
If he's healthy, we could really do some damage.

This is it. It's 100% going to dictate our season. If KM and our OL stay healthy he has an endless assortment of weapons. Even if a top WR goes down. I feel like we have enough depth between JJ, JA, JJ, TF and some of the youngins to weather that. We have depth at RB also. Just need the OL and KM to stay healthy

Liked:
#18 · Aug 14, 9:10 AM CT
supafreak84
Joined Jan 2014
1,702 posts
Rep: 1,615

StickierBuns wrote:

Damned if you do or damned if you don't. I'm a Viking's fan. Ultimately, the name on the back of the jersey doesn't mean anything without wins. I guess the alternative is too just piss and moan all year about JJ not being QB1 and stink the board up? That's not me. I don't view this as losing or winning, its always been my opinion, although strongly worded sometimes, about JJ. 🙄

I'm with you cheering for whomever plays quarterback, however, that doesn't mean we are wrong about our concerns with Murray. An entire season to play out stll and as has been mentioned a million times, Murray has played what, six games or less in each of the last two seasons? If McCarthy sticks on the roster...he'll inevitably get a shot at some point, and when it happens, and he plays well. I can't wait to hear the media falling all over themselves to credit OConnell. They will be fighting each other to see who can heap on the most praise.

Liked:
#19 · Aug 14, 9:11 AM CT
purplefaithful
Joined May 2013
8,858 posts
Rep: 5,523

The Vikings believe in Kyler Murray, even though the Cardinals had seen enough.

Here’s why.

CANTON, Ohio – It’s hard for the Arizona Cardinals to sugarcoat their true thoughts on Kyler Murray. Not when they chose to pay him $36.8 million to go away and never play for them again.

Now in Minnesota, Murray was named the Vikings’ starting quarterback this week.

Cardinals first-year head coach Mike LaFleur didn’t even try to sugarcoat it. He shrugged when asked after last week’s Hall of Fame game how long it took him and his players to put Murray’s seven-year stint behind them.

“Pretty quickly,” he said. “Once we made the decision [to release him on March 11], it was, ‘The show goes on.’ That’s the quarterback all the way down to the punter to any coach. My best to both parties. And, so, well, here we are.”

Asked for his response five days later, on the day he officially beat out J.J. McCarthy, Murray snickered and said, “Honestly, I’m not too worried about what’s going on over there. Focused on what I got going on here, in Minnesota. Glad to be here. Loved every part of being here. Focused on the future.”

The Vikings are betting that what went wrong for Murray in Arizona — questions about his work ethic and leadership, injuries and deteriorating relationships — will be nonissues in Minnesota.

The breakup with the Cardinals was about as ugly as the courtship was promising.

On April 25, 2019, Murray walked across the stage in Nashville as the No. 1 overall pick in the NFL draft — selected by the historically dysfunctional Cardinals in an apparent match made in gridiron heaven. It was Arizona’s first No. 1 overall pick since taking quarterback King Hill in 1958.

Murray was the Heisman Trophy winner from Oklahoma, a 5-10 dual-threat dynamo who went 42-0 while leading Allen High to three straight Texas state titles.

The Cardinals, meanwhile, were rolling the dice on new head coach Kliff Kingsbury and his innovative offense. The former Texas Tech coach supposedly had a leg up, having built a relationship with Murray while recruiting him out of high school.

The Cardinals went 5-10-1, but Murray played all 16 games while winning NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year. A year later, he again played all 16 games, going 8-8 while earning the first of back-to-back Pro Bowl nods.

Murray’s star was rising. The highlights were electric. The how’d-he-do-that?! runs. The escapability. A game-winning walk-off touchdown pass to DeAndre Hopkins against Buffalo was dubbed the “Hail Murray!”

“Kyler is immensely talented,” said Cardinals Hall of Fame receiver and Minneapolis native Larry Fitzgerald Jr., whose last season was 2020. “He’s a terrific athlete. He processes information quickly. He’s smart. The Vikings got a guy who is fully capable. If things don’t go the way they want, it’s not because Kyler doesn’t have the physical attributes.”

The high point of Murray’s Cardinals stint came in 2021, when he led the Cardinals to a 7-0 start and an 8-1 record before missing three games. In a 34-33 home win over the Vikings in Week 2, he completed 80.6% of his passes for 400 yards and three touchdowns while also running for a touchdown.

Murray’s only playoff appearance came that year. It wasn’t pretty. The Cardinals lost at the Rams 34-11 in the wild-card round as Murray completed 19 of 34 passes for 137 yards, no touchdowns and two interceptions.

How Kyler Murray’s relationship with the Arizona Cardinals unraveled

Murray still had two years on his contract when then-general manager Steve Keim surprised some by giving the quarterback a five-year, $230.5 million extension with $160 million guaranteed. Almost immediately, a controversy erupted that fractured Murray’s relationship with the team and has followed him ever since.

Within weeks, an unusual clause in the contract leaked to the media. It required Murray to spend four hours on “independent study” during game weeks — without being distracted by TV, the internet or video games. Failure to comply would put him in default of the contract.

The ensuing firestorm raised questions about Murray’s work ethic — and about why the Cardinals would give that kind of money to a franchise quarterback they felt needed such a clause.

Kingsbury said he wasn’t surprised by the clause “because my man’s got a quarter billion dollars.” Intended as a joke, the comment fell flat. Kingsbury later said the clause was unnecessary.

As teammates fielded questions about the clause, an increasingly upset Murray held an impromptu news conference after practice. He defended his work ethic and claimed the allegations that he doesn’t watch game film were “disrespectful” and “almost a joke.”

A two-sport star who also played outfielder in baseball at Oklahoma, Murray went on to say, “People can’t comprehend the amount of time that it takes to do two sports at a high level in college, let alone be the first person to do it ever at my size. It’s funny.”

The Cardinals relented, removing the clause and publicly reaffirming their confidence in Murray.

The damage was done, however. Murray never played up to his contract while the Cardinals fell short in surrounding him with enough talent and coaching. Kingsbury had a falling out with Murray and was fired after a 2022 season in which Murray went 3-8 in 11 starts because of a torn ACL.

Jonathan Gannon was hired in 2023, when Murray missed nine games while recovering from his knee injury. A promising relationship between the two fizzled the following season, when Arizona lost five of its final seven games to finish 8-9 and miss the playoffs.

Murray injured his foot five games into last season, with Arizona 2-3. The team never clarified whether Murray was healthy enough to return. A traditional recovery timetable suggested he could have returned, but the Cardinals stuck with Jacoby Brissett, who threw 23 touchdown passes and eight interceptions while posting a 1-11 record.

General manager Monti Ossenfort, a native of Luverne, Minn., fired Gannon, hired LaFleur and released Murray. Releasing Murray allowed the Cardinals to split $55 million in dead cap money over two seasons and avoid paying him another $19.2 million in 2027.


“Was I surprised about Kyler? No,” Brissett said earlier this month after Arizona’s 33-30 loss to Carolina in the Hall of Fame game. “It’s the business of football.”

While the Vikings got Murray for the $1.3 million league minimum, the Cardinals re-signed Brissett to a one-year, $15.5 million guaranteed deal, signed veteran QB Gardner Minshew and drafted Carson Beck in the third round. LaFleur said he likes the leadership coming from his new quarterback room.

Leadership, like work ethic, has long been a hot-button issue with Murray. Those close to him in Arizona say he’s naturally introverted. Quiet. Private. Sometimes perceived as aloof or uncaring. He prefers to lead by example on the field and go home.

Those traits might go unnoticed at another position. At quarterback, they helped make Murray a divisive figure in Arizona.


Strib

Hurry-up Vikings, we ain't getting any younger! 

Liked:
#20 · Aug 14, 9:17 AM CT
purplefaithful
Joined May 2013
8,858 posts
Rep: 5,523

Vikings believe Kyler Murray can succeed with them

Vikings coach Kevin O’Connell isn’t concerned about all that. Or Murray’s 38-48-1 career record.

He loves the big-swing potential that comes with a motivated Murray dialed in and, frankly, playing for his next big contract. He loves the career completion percentage of 67.1 and the 121-60 touchdown-to-interception differential.

He also loves that Murray is only 29.

O’Connell sees leadership potential in Murray’s “ultra competitiveness,” something that was evident when Murray and fellow future No. 1 overall pick Baker Mayfield were teammates at Oklahoma.

“He may not be the rah-rah guy or the guy everybody looks to for that energy and explosion like some of the other captains,” O’Connell said. “But I think it’s going to be his presence and his professional approach and his improvement and comfort that will bring out the best version of him [as a leader].”

O’Connell’s offense is complex and difficult to learn, but the Vikings believe Murray can thrive in it with a better supporting cast. They saw it with Sam Darnold at QB in 2024, when the Vikings won 14 games and O’Connell was named NFL Coach of the Year.

“It’s different here,” said Vikings cornerback Byron Murphy Jr., who was in Murray’s draft class with the Cardinals. “The culture here. It’s just different. I’m excited about what Kyler can do this year.”

Murray isn’t trying to force his leadership role with the Vikings.

“I’m new here,” he said. “Guys understand I like to lead by example. As the days go on, as guys get to know me more, as I get to prove myself on the field, whatever it is, the leadership stuff is organic, natural.”

The pressure to get this season right — to capitalize on O’Connell and the Vikings’ talent and go deeper into the playoffs than in 2024, when Minnesota’s 14-win season ended in the wild-card round — seems immense.

Murray, after all, is writing his NFL future in 2026. He joins Mayfield (2018), Jared Goff (2016), Jameis Winston (2015), Andrew Luck (2012), Cam Newton (2011) and Sam Bradford (2010) as seven consecutive quarterbacks selected No. 1 overall to move on from the team that drafted them before their 31st birthday.

What say you, Kyler?

“Pressure? No. I don’t feel any pressure,” he said on the day he was named the starter. “I look at this like a blessing. I get to play the game that I love every single day. I truly mean it. No pressure at all. Just come out here and play the game I love to play. Be myself. Let the chips fall where they may. And I don’t got to do too much. I got a great supporting cast around me that I want to play for.”

And a team that wants him, too. Unlike Arizona.

Strib

Hurry-up Vikings, we ain't getting any younger! 

Liked:
#21 · Aug 14, 9:18 AM CT
Log in to reply.

Edit Post (mod action — author will see a notice)

Warn Poster

Suspend User (3 days)

The user will be suspended for 3 days and will receive an email with the reason and information about how to appeal.

Forum The Longship The case for Kyler Murray
Return to top ↑

Welcome to VikeFans!

Welcome back, Skol fans! This is our new home. Log in with your username or email and your existing password.


Be sure to check out the How To's and Questions forum for guides on getting around the new site, and use the Help Request forum if you run into anything that you need help with. Skol!

You belong here, Vikings fan.

Join the VikeFans community to share your takes, react to posts, and talk Vikings with fans who get it.